Jawed
1000+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Dec 7, 2014
- Posts
- 1,124
- Likes
- 582
So this evening I was briefly sat not listening to music and I could hear hiss from my speakers! That's not right I thought, DAVE driving my speakers (91dB/W/m at 1.6m listening distance) is absolutely silent. Why is there hiss? OK, so I've got the volume a bit louder than normal, but DAVE never gave me hiss before I got HMS.
So then I played with inputs and discovered that HMS being active is causing the hiss! If I stop the audio to HMS then the hiss disappears and I'm back to blissful silence from DAVE.
So, remembering that Blu 2 has a dither option switch which can be used when connecting Blu 2 to a non-Chord DAC, I thought about bit depth. With Blu 2 the dither is used to create a 16-bit output that is compatible with an old type of DAC.
So on my computer I changed the bit-depth to 24-bit, instead of the default 16-bit. Now, there's no hiss from DAVE even when "silence" is playing through HMS. So it seems that HMS detects that the input is 16-bit and it outputs dithered 16-bit audio (at 705.6 KHz). The dithering is what I was hearing as hiss with HMS feeding into DAVE.
This seems to be a problem though: anyone who is using a CD transport into HMS is feeding HMS with 16-bit data. HMS then adds dither. The dither is completely pointless if you have a Chord DAC. And worse than that, the dither is audible!
@Rob Watts is this behaviour by HMS intentional? This seems like a bug to me. It's easy for me to solve this problem, but anyone using a CD transport into HMS seems to be stuck! Also I suspect anyone using a streamer that outputs 16-bit audio will have the same problem. In my setup I'm using optical. Perhaps this problem only affects S/PDIF audio (optical and electrical), so USB is fine?
Now playing: Stephen Cleobury, Choir of King's College Cambridge etc. - Lassus: Choral Music
So then I played with inputs and discovered that HMS being active is causing the hiss! If I stop the audio to HMS then the hiss disappears and I'm back to blissful silence from DAVE.
So, remembering that Blu 2 has a dither option switch which can be used when connecting Blu 2 to a non-Chord DAC, I thought about bit depth. With Blu 2 the dither is used to create a 16-bit output that is compatible with an old type of DAC.
So on my computer I changed the bit-depth to 24-bit, instead of the default 16-bit. Now, there's no hiss from DAVE even when "silence" is playing through HMS. So it seems that HMS detects that the input is 16-bit and it outputs dithered 16-bit audio (at 705.6 KHz). The dithering is what I was hearing as hiss with HMS feeding into DAVE.
This seems to be a problem though: anyone who is using a CD transport into HMS is feeding HMS with 16-bit data. HMS then adds dither. The dither is completely pointless if you have a Chord DAC. And worse than that, the dither is audible!
@Rob Watts is this behaviour by HMS intentional? This seems like a bug to me. It's easy for me to solve this problem, but anyone using a CD transport into HMS seems to be stuck! Also I suspect anyone using a streamer that outputs 16-bit audio will have the same problem. In my setup I'm using optical. Perhaps this problem only affects S/PDIF audio (optical and electrical), so USB is fine?
Now playing: Stephen Cleobury, Choir of King's College Cambridge etc. - Lassus: Choral Music