I think I found the pairing I was looking for. Some of you may remember my
earlier post about Sennheiser HE-1, which I had a chance to audition for 4 hours last week. I compared it to my AB-1266 (out of dCS Bartok) and was very surprised that HE-1 had the amount of bass it did, but it still was not as good as AB-1266 for electronic music (that has no reference to real life). However, this was a dangerous outing, as I fell in love with HE-1's mids, and its intimate soundstage. Vocal heavy tracks (even synth-pop) just sounded so wonderful. That left me with a theory, that my AB-1266 is king for EDM, anything that is heavily altered or digital, but I need another pair of headphones for the rest that stems from real life sounds. I wanted something that is of the same level of quality in terms of resolution. So I contacted my dealer who lent me broken in Focal Utopia and Hifiman Susvara. I was expecting both to sound fantastic, but differ in their soundstage representation - Susvara wide and open; Utopia forward and intimate. I wanted something that would be closer to HE-1, so I expected to like Utopia more. Boy, I was wrong.
As you can see I am driving Susvara off Bartok, which puts out 2.8 W into 66 Ohm, which many of you will say it is underpowered. Do not worry, I have Viva Egoista 845 en route. But I wanted to share with you my first initial impressions anyway, I hope you don't mind. Susvara impressed me with its ability to render the stage intimately when asked for (as I liked in HE-1), but wide (less wide than AB-1266) on music that was recorded that way. Susvara's mids are forward and centre (compared to cold and recessed AB-1266, which puts the singer 15 meters away) so Susvara works very well for vocal heavy songs. I expected Susvara to sound more natural (closer to real life, on pianos and strings) and I can confirm it does. Now, what came to me as a surprise is how indie rock sounds to me - I used to listen to it in the past, but did not find it well recorded/mastered, so I went into EDM instead. Going back to this old genre, I love it on Susvara, it sounds "familiar".
So is Susvara a keeper? Let's see how its sound changes when I put it on more powerful amplifier. I am worried that the soundstage will expand too much and it will loose its intimacy on songs that ask for it (my main reason for searching for a second pair of headphones after all). Worth mentioning that Susvara to my ears is as detailed as AB-1266 or HE-1, which unfortunately I cannot say about the other headphone (Utopia, which mids work for me well, as they are dead centre, very forward and intimate). Please note, these are my first impressions after 2-3 hours non stop listening, not days, and I have them both until next week. I will be getting Valkyria for comparison, maybe it wows me even more, who knows.
Long story short: I have a theory now, AB-1266 being the king for anything EDM (or everything digital), and Susvara being queen for anything acoustic (sounds that have a real life counterpart). If I had to rate AB-1266, Susvara and HE-1 on aspects that are important to me, it would be
Bass quantity (quality all equal): AB-1266 > HE-1 > Susvara
Soundstage: (Expansive) AB-1266 > Susvara > HE-1 (intimate)
Mids: (luxurious and forward): HE-1 > Susvara > AB-1266 (cold and recessed)
Neutrality: (real life) Susvara > HE-1 > AB-1266 (coloured)
Resolution: (resolution) AB-1266 > Susvara > HE-1 (smoothness)
Obviously above-mentioned will change once Viva Egoista 845 is added to the equation, as I suspect Susvara to be underpowered (but still, sounds amazing out of Bartok). What makes me very happy is that dCS Bartok + Viva Egoista 845 + AB-1266 AND Susvara together cost around 42 000 Eur, which is 18 000 Eur less than HE-1, which only tops it in luxurious and intimate mids, just one specific genre. On other types, Susvara and AB-1266 trumps HE-1 to my ears. And that is still without actually listening to Viva Egoista 845, properly driving both AB-1266 and Susvara. Imagine how will that sound, haha.
Anyway, please take these words with a grain of salt. I am excited little kid, I mean no offense to others and most importantly, I do not want to dismiss anyone else's experiences. My ears are just that, my ears, there are flawed and biased. But I vote with my money, so at least rest assured, I put money where my mouth is. Thanks for reading.