pennylane
500+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Feb 10, 2002
- Posts
- 772
- Likes
- 16
Quote:
Well I wouldn't say the album version of Videotape is "better" than the live one, but I think it fits the mood of the song/album more appropriately.
While there are exceptions, I have to say that by and large, I've thought Radiohead's studio versions of songs fit well in the album context (ie, one part of a whole), while their live versions fit well live (ie, one individual song). I need more listens with the live and album versions of each song to decide if I feel the same way with In Rainbows.
Originally Posted by infinitesymphony /img/forum/go_quote.gif Yeah, I said something similar earlier in the thread... But, I understand why they changed it. I think that it just rocked out too hard for its own good, and that ending the album with so much energy may have ruined the mood. I'm sure that they at least attempted the live version in the studio, and maybe we'll hear an alternate version some day. For what it's worth, my girlfriend likes the new version better. She said it reminded her of listening to the minimalist music of Arvo Part, where each repetition subtly changes the meaning and tone of the song. |
Well I wouldn't say the album version of Videotape is "better" than the live one, but I think it fits the mood of the song/album more appropriately.
While there are exceptions, I have to say that by and large, I've thought Radiohead's studio versions of songs fit well in the album context (ie, one part of a whole), while their live versions fit well live (ie, one individual song). I need more listens with the live and album versions of each song to decide if I feel the same way with In Rainbows.