needmoretoys
100+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2005
- Posts
- 238
- Likes
- 46
Exactly. James has indicated this on several posts. Apparently not everyone has the ability to comprehend this."Scientific empiricism" .... seriously?! Actually James gave a perfectly good 'empirical' justification ... that it takes a week to test an app and that would just be to find the bugs it causes, much less actually fix them. Testing the stability of 3rd party software on an OS it wasn't designed for is expensive and complex and even with rigorous checking there will be points of failure that were missed. The M6 is a low cost DAP with one of the highest price performance ratios of any player around right now. That means the profit margins are very tight - the business model is low profit, high volume sales. Every request for another app whitelisted is effectively a demand that FiiO spend thousands adding a feature that you want. Sure, we all want stuff, but that's just not how the business model works for this kind of product.
They are trying to squeeze maximum performance out of a relatively cheap chip - so the software approach is a "walled garden" - a stripped down OS and a short list of approved apps. For this kind of product OS stability and "doing what it says on the box" are essential to the kind of sales volume they need to be able to sell it at this price. That stability has to be protected because a crashy OS will kill the product and damage the company rep. So I totally get why they need to be super dooper careful with new apps. Approving an app that causes functionality problems (and a resulting wave of complaints) would do 1000 times more damage to sales than the small number of potential customers who regard the availability of some specific app as a dealbreaker. This is absolutely a mass market product and (despite what a lot of head fi-ers seem to think) the people who post to this kind of forum are not the mass market. This forum right here is what you call a "niche". (Not a criticism - I love a niche, but I am pretty sure their design choices are based on actual market research).
Personally I think this is a brilliant design approach and I hope FiiO continue to extremely careful about what additional apps are allowed over the wall. I am the kind of user who places a high value on product reliability, so the fact that they are prioritising reliability is a big tick in favour of the product. The software limitations of the M6 are what makes the low price point possible. If you really need to run 3rd party apps that were designed for full android then pony up and buy a unit that runs full android.