I start to realize there may be bigger variations across stock pads on the D7200 than we'd assume.
1. The memory foam gets softer with heat and shrinks, hence it sounds a bit different after a few minutes of literal warm-up then when just putting on the headphones. If you press the headphones to the ears after warm-up, notice how the sound changes as the drivers get slightly closed to the ears and the air volume to be driven shrinks. With a given headphone there are settings/positions/warm-up states of the stock pads that sound better than others.
Even bigger changes happen with other pads that have different mass and mass distribution inside the ear pads.
2. Also, I have tried 3 pairs of foam dampers around the TH900 drivers and all sounded different. Unfortunately the Denon foam dampers are glued on the housing and I won't remove them, but there is a high chance that sample variation has an effect here, too.
So my theory for the rather divergent opinions about the D7200 is that this might be related to sample variation in the pads and in the foam damping around the drivers (also foam):
- The dampers affect how much midrange gets through from the cups, i.e. affect the midrange ringing/honkiness factor.
- The pads are more responsible for bass level, impact and sound stage changes.
There is enough variation that may be considerable from sample to sample. I have heard two samples of D7200, and they did sound slightly different, but it is still the same character. This is not enough to prove a theory, but I have a good confidence it's still valid.
Overall I prefer other pads, such as the TH900 pads with trimmed foam, or the Chinese pads when used with the trimmed foam from the TH900 pads
. However, the headphones measure rather well with the stock pads, so I cannot complain much. Since the FR doesn't change as much with pad changes than the sound, I might order replacement Denon pads, open them and either trim or replace the foam in them to see what would work better: a modded Denon pad, or bigger inner/outer diameter pads.
Earlier in this thread somebody suggested the D7200 sounds better when rotating the pads so that the thicker part is in front (change the cables if you rotate the pads + headphone). I have dismissed that on theoretical grounds, but there is a change and it's indeed more pleasant with a wide range of music. So much about theory
. Yet, I still hear the midrange problems I want to fix, albeit a bit diminished.
You can also try to rotate the pads backwards about 10-30 degrees, depending on your head shape, in order to obtain the best seal. I use it at about 15 degrees backwards and prefer it to the ones rotated 180 degrees.
The conclusion is that try to listen to the pair you are buying (it actually applies to all headphones, but especially to the D7200/TH900 types). It may be well worth, even if you pay more, since you can save a lot of tinkering time and will know for sure.