slowpogo
500+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2007
- Posts
- 755
- Likes
- 11
B&W C5
Brainwavz B2
NAD HP20
Polk Nue Voe
RHA MA750i
HiFiMan RE-400
RBH EP-1
These are the in-ear headphones I've auditioned over the last 10 days or so. I listened through my iPhone, to 320k+ AAC files or lossless with the EQ "off" or "flat." All of them, other than maybe the NAD, seem well-known in these parts. Lots of people like them. In all honesty, though some of them did some things very well, I was not too impressed by any of them overall. Not enough to keep anyway.
It mostly comes down to BASS. Only the RE-400 and B2 did not have immediately overwhelming bass. With the others, it was like, oh my GOD that's WAYYYY too much bass! You know how you can cover your mouth while you're talking, and your speech goes from normal to being unintelligibly drowned in bassy resonance? That's pretty much how most of these headphones sounded to me. Like, shocking that anyone would enjoy the sound, it was so ridiculously drowned out in low-end.
My first go-too track to test these ended up being "Distant Sun" by Crowded House. It starts with a single strummed acoustic guitar, and sounds very balanced and natural with my AKG K701's. With most of the above headphones, however, this simple acoustic guitar was awash in bassy resonance: completely unrealistic sounding, and impossible to enjoy. I would then move on to a classical recording of Ravel's "Le Tombeau de Couperin," then John Coltrane, Radiohead, and finally Sunny Day Real Estate (which is the "heaviest" thing I generally listen to). This seemed to cover all my bases in as few tracks as possible. I tried all the different tips that would fit. My ear canals are small, so often only the smallest one or two pairs included will fit me. I have a variety pack from MEElectronics with a few more options. Anyway, I never had trouble getting a good seal, and I experimented with the degree of seal as much as I could. Different tips affected soundstage or isolation the most but didn't typically help much with bass.
I really enjoyed the detail and musicality of the C5, but even with the "Bass Reducer" EQ setting on iPhone it was just too dark (and the ear loop thing just KILLED my right ear). The RE-400's are much more mid-centric, and using the "Classical" iPhone EQ tamed the mids just a bit and sounded very balanced; alas, the general character was still a bit "gray" and uninvolving to me. These two were the closest to being keepers.
I'm running out of options, I feel. Etymotics seem to be up my alley, the way people describe the sound, but the extreme isolation bothers me: I want to wear these while I'm walking the street or running. I'm thinking about trying the Bang and Olufsen Beoplay H3 next.
Nobody generally responds to my posts here anymore. I feel like I'm talking to myself (and I know my posts are super long). But please, any advice from people who feel like I do is very appreciated, on what to try which is actually somewhat neutral sounding.
Brainwavz B2
NAD HP20
Polk Nue Voe
RHA MA750i
HiFiMan RE-400
RBH EP-1
These are the in-ear headphones I've auditioned over the last 10 days or so. I listened through my iPhone, to 320k+ AAC files or lossless with the EQ "off" or "flat." All of them, other than maybe the NAD, seem well-known in these parts. Lots of people like them. In all honesty, though some of them did some things very well, I was not too impressed by any of them overall. Not enough to keep anyway.
It mostly comes down to BASS. Only the RE-400 and B2 did not have immediately overwhelming bass. With the others, it was like, oh my GOD that's WAYYYY too much bass! You know how you can cover your mouth while you're talking, and your speech goes from normal to being unintelligibly drowned in bassy resonance? That's pretty much how most of these headphones sounded to me. Like, shocking that anyone would enjoy the sound, it was so ridiculously drowned out in low-end.
My first go-too track to test these ended up being "Distant Sun" by Crowded House. It starts with a single strummed acoustic guitar, and sounds very balanced and natural with my AKG K701's. With most of the above headphones, however, this simple acoustic guitar was awash in bassy resonance: completely unrealistic sounding, and impossible to enjoy. I would then move on to a classical recording of Ravel's "Le Tombeau de Couperin," then John Coltrane, Radiohead, and finally Sunny Day Real Estate (which is the "heaviest" thing I generally listen to). This seemed to cover all my bases in as few tracks as possible. I tried all the different tips that would fit. My ear canals are small, so often only the smallest one or two pairs included will fit me. I have a variety pack from MEElectronics with a few more options. Anyway, I never had trouble getting a good seal, and I experimented with the degree of seal as much as I could. Different tips affected soundstage or isolation the most but didn't typically help much with bass.
I really enjoyed the detail and musicality of the C5, but even with the "Bass Reducer" EQ setting on iPhone it was just too dark (and the ear loop thing just KILLED my right ear). The RE-400's are much more mid-centric, and using the "Classical" iPhone EQ tamed the mids just a bit and sounded very balanced; alas, the general character was still a bit "gray" and uninvolving to me. These two were the closest to being keepers.
I'm running out of options, I feel. Etymotics seem to be up my alley, the way people describe the sound, but the extreme isolation bothers me: I want to wear these while I'm walking the street or running. I'm thinking about trying the Bang and Olufsen Beoplay H3 next.
Nobody generally responds to my posts here anymore. I feel like I'm talking to myself (and I know my posts are super long). But please, any advice from people who feel like I do is very appreciated, on what to try which is actually somewhat neutral sounding.