At first I thought you meant The Absolute Sound magazine. Oh well.
Your argument is an old one, and frankly it comes down to your audio philosophy. Are you interested in find the most neutral, uncoloured phones, those that will alter the sound the least, or are you in the hobby purely for experimenting and finding the "funnest" sound? It seems to me a lot of younger posters here fall into the latter category. You rarely see them discussing accuracy or neutrality, but rather what phone sounds best on a particular recording, even to posting links to the recording (which is something I could probably live without, but then I'm just an old fart). Those of a more traditional bent, such as myself, are looking for what best resembles the original goal of hi-fi--the headphone that least molests and assaults the virginal sound before it gets to us. When I hear a phone described as "fun" these days I head in the opposite direction. When I see a poster--especially a younger poster, so well as I can identify them--complaining about a phone being boring or sterile, my interest is immediately piqued. That might sound cynical, but it's a technique I find surprisingly useful. Most younger posters are seeking a sound that will enhance the particular genre of popular music they favour, whereas I seek a sound that will simply get out of the way of the signal coming through, so far as that's possible.
Of course some will ask, how do I know what the signal actually sounds like, since I only ever hear it through a transducer? Well, I go to orchestral concerts and trust my audio memory (yes, I'm into classical. I told you I was an old fart). I've tried many, many phones (I told you I was an old...oh never mind) and I pretty much know instantly which phones take me back to the concert hall and which leave me standing out in the street disappointed, It's not really rocket science, at least, not with acoustic music. Of course, if I were into electronic stuff, or maybe rap, it might be a different story, and I can see that finding the right phone for a genre already pre-distorted--or "enhanced" to some degree--could be a real pain in the butt. So maybe you all ought to switch to classical and save yourself a lot of....no, no, I didn't say that...forget I said that...