Paulus XII
Formerly known as FW214b
Definitely avoid W40. Jump into W60 if you can.
Definitely avoid W40. Jump into W60 if you can.
Little justifications/explications will be welcome
I want opinion here from acoustic music listener (jazz/classical). I already test Shure 535/846, Grado GR10, ie800, ie80, Etymotics sound, and I want to give a try to Westone now.
I'm looking in order of priority, a neutral & balanced warm sound, can be laid back but with a looooooot of definition. Not mids forward like Shure 535, or too much deep bass emphasis like Shure 846. I prefer balance bass that sound very precise (very important on jazz with acoustic bass), instead of too much deep bass (that is awsome for rock, but not for classical/jazz). I didn't like treble on ie800, too bright for my taste, I'm very sensitive in that range), Grado GR10 (not e) was not my cup of tea too (sadly, because what a nice fitting in the ear), I found piano sonata a lot too aggressive for my taste, but on vocal, what a nice fit. Of course all this it's a question of taste, they are not facts, but observations/experiences. So, please, it's not a debate on my perception, but want recommendation base on my "subjective observation/perception/experience". So, guys, for acoustical music, base on my experiences, W40 or W60 you recommend to me ? (or maybe, even a W20?) I don't mind/care of prices here, but I learn that expensive doesn't always mean better in audio too. I'm just looking for a sound that fit MY taste. If it cost $300 fine, I'll save for something else (a better DAC,etc), but if it "need" to cost $1500, well, bad for my wallet, but, finally, my ear will have gratitude for me
Westone's never been afraid to push the technological boundaries so to speak; while Shure is more "conservative" here.
Sorry but I can't agree. The W60 is 3x dual BA's with a 3 way crossover, Westone just stuffed them in a small housing, they didn't exactly innovate much on their own. The SE846 also using 3 way crossover technically has more innovation with it's low pass filter and exchangeable filters, Shure also designs their own BA's while Westone uses off the shelf BA's. Also bear in mind that the BA's in the W60 are smaller than the BA's in the SE846, which would likely mean 846 has more headroom (higher power ceiling, lower distortion rate). Just to be clear, I dislike both Shure and Westone house sound.
@MacedonianHero - Did you just state that more BA is always better than less? Even though they may be smaller and dual BAs? Both use 3 way crossovers. If Westone was using a 6 way crossover I'd call it less of a marketing gimmick. Why are the exchangeable filters gimmicky when they do change the sound? I haven't heard the W60's so can't really comment on the sound, but I do think that the SE846 lacks crystal clear top end and the mids/vocals are very forward. The powerful bass works for most modern music I listen to. I still prefer my IE800s more, but these are good for different types of music. BTW the IE800 is only one driver, so I guess that makes it worse in your mind?
@MacedonianHero - Did you just state that more BA is always better than less? Even though they may be smaller and dual BAs? Both use 3 way crossovers. If Westone was using a 6 way crossover I'd call it less of a marketing gimmick. Why are the exchangeable filters gimmicky when they do change the sound? I haven't heard the W60's so can't really comment on the sound, but I do think that the SE846 lacks crystal clear top end and the mids/vocals are very forward. The powerful bass works for most modern music I listen to. I still prefer my IE800s more, but these are good for different types of music. BTW the IE800 is only one driver, so I guess that makes it worse in your mind?
The only thing that suppose to interest us, is, SQ, comfort, and third, the ratio performance/price. Price depend on your budget. Removing price from the equation, we want the one that sound better than the other, that's all. I have the 846, and yes, I change filter, depend on what tips I use, comply, or silicone. It's a flexibility I like on 846, that westone don't have. It's a fact.
The only thing that suppose to interest us, is, SQ, comfort, and third, the ratio performance/price. Price depend on your budget. Removing price from the equation, we want the one that sound better than the other, that's all. I have the 846, and yes, I change filter, depend on what tips I use, comply, or silicone. It's a flexibility I like on 846, that westone don't have. It's a fact.