I am in the queue to upgrade my Yggy to an Analog 2, and am looking for impressions from those who have used both the original and upgraded DAC with either a KGSSHV Carbon, Stax 009, or preferably both.
I've been through a multi-month DAC hunt to try and replace the Yggy with something superior. In my main rig I have an LCD-4 (V281) and an 009 (KGSSHV) Carbon. Originally, I used a Vega with the LCD-4 and the original Yggy with my 009. To my ears, the LCD-4 needs a bright DAC, and the 009 needs a more neutral DAC. I bought a Bricasti M1 SE in the hopes that it would fall in between the Vega and Yggy (in terms of brightness) and provide superior soundstaging, imaging - and the tonality I was looking for.
The M1 synergizes well with the LCD-4, and provided great sound with the 009 - or so I thought. I like a bright sound with forward mids, and while I greatly enjoy the sound with the 009, it is too fatiguing. I wanted a little more bite in the upper mids than the Yggy provides, and the M1 delivers - but my ears hurt within 30 minutes. I have tried more expensive and less expensive DACS than the Yggy, in addition to the M1 - Aqua La Scala, Hugo TT, NAD M51, Chord2qute, Vega - etc. I tried the new 009S with the the M1, and while I still love the mids, it's become too dark and dry up top now!
Anyway - to cut to the chase, the Yggy is closest to the perfect DAC with this combo. From a tonality standpoint, Highs are just right, I would like a hair more bite in the mids - but I could easily live with it, bass is both quantitatively and qualitatively strong, and no fatigue. It's crazy, the Carbon/009 is soooooo picky (to my ears) and the Yggy is the only DAC that I've tried that I've been able to achieve great synergy ( I'm sure there are more out there, just not DACs I've tried in my system.)
Based on this experience, I'm concerned the Analog 2 will alter the tonality - and potentially jeopardize this synergy. Once I make the upgrade, there is no going back - so want to ensure, if it is an improvement - it doesn't take away the thing I find special about the Yggy>Carbon>009 combo. Most importantly, the highs are spot on, and the Yggy's midrange seems to be at just the right balance to be revealing while not becoming fatiguing.
Given what I appreciate about the Yggy, how does the Analog 2 affect tonality? I-m most concerned about not losing highs, and that if the midrange has changed at all - it's not pushed forward more than slightly (and not pushed back farther). I'm all for other improvements in noise floor, imaging, depth, etc.
Appreciate any opinions on this. Further, any reccomendations on DACs that match the Yggy's tonality to a T - but are superior, or different in other ways. MSB Analog? Total Dac? Holo Spring?
Thanks for your help.