Quote:
Originally Posted by senn_liu /img/forum/go_quote.gif
joeoboe, any idea how the optical output from your western digital media player compares with usb output from a computer through the compass?
deciding between getting the media player or a cheap laptop myself.
|
I have been VERY happy with the Western Digital's sound. It's interface is simple and works well... although it will never approach the flexibility of MediaMonkey or even Foobar ( both of which I like quite a bit).
The advantages I see for the Western Digital Media player are:
1. COMPLETELY silent... no fans at all.
2. Plays every file I can throw at it... including Hi rez (96/24) FLAC.
3. It only costs $100USD.
4. Since it uses up to 2 external USB hard drives, it is flexible AND it encourages you to keep you music library backed up... so if you main computer with all your stuff goes south, you still have all your ripped music files sitting on another hard drive.
Also, in the past I have used USB DACs and found them limited to 16 bit 48Hz. My understanding was this was a limitation of the PCM 2xxx series of chips or perhaps Windows itself... although I know certain devices like the Benchmark use custom programmed chips that can get higher rez from USB... so I think the limitation is in the chipset.
The Western digital Media Player is fine playing hi rez files.
A few pages back, there was talk about a "buffered cd player" being the ideal platform since you eliminate all the operating system garbage and the noisy computer environment ( both audible and electrical noise). I was thinking at that time, "Gee... the Western Digital Media Player IS that device pretty much... but it eliminates the OTHER source of jitter... the cd drive!"
Of course, there are plenty of reasons to go with a computer as a source ( flexibility and powerful processing being 2 that come to mind) and arguments can be made for every single input source, be it USB, Coax, Optical... and I am sure there are BNC proponents out there scoffing at the rest of us!
I
can say that I have been VERY pleased with the results I have gotten with the Western Digital player used into the optical inputs of the Compass.