SONY A17 VS FIIO X3
finally my replacement for the fiio x3 arrived today so i had a brief shootout agains t one and other
Albums tested
- Dr. Chesky's sampler that come with fiio x3 (copied it to micro SD) [24/192] Dr. chesky as artist i think
- Naxos 25th Anniversary: Greatest Violin Concertos: Bach & Vivaldi [16/44.1] Capella Istropolitana & Takako Nishizaki (Bach violin cto. in E major)
- Beethove the complete Piano sonata CD 3 [16/44.1] Vladimir Ashkenazi (sonata No. 7)
- Thomas Tallis The Complete Works- Music for Queen Elizabeth [16/44.1] Chapelle du Roi & Alistair Dixon (Spem in Alium, NOPE NO BLOODY SHADES OF GRAY and no cheating like *cough* The King's Singers *cough* with *cough* Multi-tracking recording technology *cough* it's the original 40-Voices motet)
Inserting the micro SD from the sony to the fiio with no problem despite being exFAT (fiio FW is 3.2) but Soooooooooooooooooooooooooooo sloooooow to scan 5, 300 FLAC... 15 minutes wow. The sony when I reinserted the SD back, took just 3 minutes (with is 64GB filled with mozart, Byrd, WF Bach and others)
FIIO x3 playing chesky was rendered quite good but like the sony walkman unable to distinguis the supposed "binaural" marvel nope nothing not even on the sony. stage was on par in oth devices for this album
Switching to Bach concerto for violin solo in E major- fiio has the erratic problem of floating trebbly instruments making the presentation so unnatural, the reverb is not detailed tought the harpsichord was more audible on the fiio than the sony, but the sony has this natural presentation with revrb, no floating violin over me.
Beethoven sonata no. 7 sounded meh! on the fiio x3. the piano just the piano, booring, on the sony this changes to enveloping soundstage, reverb and nice finer details like hamers hitting strings are heard on the sony.
Chesky's was shocking for me given the nature of MDR-1R (XBA-H3 was a total disaster on the sony A17, they want an amp), the fiio rendered the organ scale (for pedal) muddy bass ont eh MDR-1R even with gain set to H, but XBA-H3 was tamed bass with impact nice neutral. On the sony the MDR-1R's achieved freaking low bass levels WOW, but H3 unbeareable boom became untoleable so i ahd to quit chesky's on the sony haha
anyways switched back to 1R's the spem in alium the sony tends to add more detail and reverberations, enveloping 3D stage, sounds less congestd than fiio x3 during super dense passages liek when all the 40 voices sounds mega powerful.
Sony sounds better than the fiio x3, but the fiio x3 reminds me of older walkmans esp. the X-series