You really want the competition reviews from the same guy ? Here
A17 vs ZX1 vs Po(r)No vs Zx2
First link 17-zx1-Pono
http://www.enjoythemusic.com/magazine/equipment/1214/Sony_NWZ_ZX1_NWZ_A17_Pono_Music_Player.htm
Second link Zx2
http://www.enjoythemusic.com/magazine/equipment/0215/Sony_NW_ZX2_Walkman_Review_Noble_Kaiser_K10.htm
I'm glad you mentioned these again, as something has been bothering me about his reviews of the ZX1 and ZX2.
His disdain for the ZX1 was so complete, and his love of the ZX2 was so complete as to baffle me.
Here are a few choice quotes from his
ZX1 review:
- The Sony NWZ-ZX1 is basically a warmed over, uninspired imho effort by Sony using the Android operating system.
- Android is a wonderful OS imho, just that piggy-backing on it gave me the feeling that for $659 Sony could have done far better.
- The Sony NWZ-ZX1 was also laggy, meaning slow to respond to user input commands.
- Sony's NWZ-ZX1 feels solidly built and generally nice overall. But, ummm, what is it with the NWZ-ZX1's huge arse?
- The Sony NWZ-ZX1 was good yet nothing that special frankly aurally. At least not for the $650 asking price as compared to the many other products available within the marketplace today.
- The laggy GUI is another deal-breaker for me, too. Take your money and look elsewhere...
So, he seems to feel that using Android is a cheap cop-out? Oh, and it's laggy. He needed to point that out twice.
Presumably, he wanted a custom OS and interface? If so, I'm not sure where all his disdain for using Android went in his ZX2 review. And as for being laggy? Well, the ZX2 uses the
same TI OMAP 4430 CPU and has the same amount of RAM as the ZX1, yet uses a slightly newer, and some could argue slightly more bloated version of Android. Strange how there's no complaints about the ZX2 being laggy.
Here's some of his
ZX2 review:
- Based on Android 4.2.2, the touchscreen and GUI work smoothly together.
- Sure it may not be ultra-lightning fast, and there might be a bit of lag when you use your finger to scroll through your music files, yet i have a feeling this is more due to the OS and nothing Sony could really do about it as 4.2.2 has an inherent very slight delay during scrolling.
- The beautiful curves remind me of a Ferrari, while in contrast the nearly twice as expensive Astell&Kern AK240 is physically more chiseled-like in styling akin to a Lamborghini.
It actually sounds like he's begrudgingly admitting that the interface is still sluggish, but he's giving it a pass. Heck, he's even resorted to making excuses for Sony (it's probably Android's fault). And while the design may be more curved than the ZX1, the ass is still there. No ranting about it this time, for some reason.
I don't post this to serve as some sort of defense of the ZX1, or some bash of the ZX2. I thought the difference in tone between the two devices was just so radically different, yet there wasn't any real logic behind the difference. Ultimately, all I can come up with is that he liked the sound signature of the ZX2 over the ZX1 so much, he was willing to forgive and overlook every design, build and interface shortcoming.