- Joined
- Aug 22, 2015
- Posts
- 753
- Likes
- 188
We can disagree over whether Apple's move was in the consumers' best interests or not, but the fact that Apple removed the analog audio jack - thereby pushing responsibility for the DAC and amp units to an external device - seems to me an unassailable fact. And no, I'm not asking phone makers to put DFR-quality DAC/amps into their phones. I would like them to, but all I'm actually asking is they include an analog audio out. Evolution would naturally lead to improvements (i.e., Beats headphones). I can temporarily live without TOTL sound quality, should I choose to leave my external DAC/amp at home, but with the audio jack gone, that choice is gone.
I agree that you wanting to carry extra gadgets around with you leaves you in a small fraction of headfi users, which in turn is a small fraction of the global population. However, I suspect the majority - like me - would just like some simple, non-clunky way to connect their headphones. (BTW, you're clearly not aware of the mark-up on these DACs/amps. The chips in these cost nowhere near $200. Apple was able to make a profit selling a $15 DAC/amp, which includes the housing, packaging, distribution, etc. Those lower costs would naturally follow from mass production.)
That's risky advice, IMHO. Any device which is not paying its royalties to Apple is subject to getting bricked at the next iOS update. That's already happened to most such non-MFi cables, leaving the users with nothing but an exotic-looking twisty-tie.
@MickeyVee - have you tried the brown Knowles dampers in your SE846? If not, don't give up on them just yet
I can't disagree that losing the analog out is negative for many people, but honestly it was been little to no inconvenience for me. They provide that lightning to 3.5 mm dongle which is about 6 inches long. I keep the dongle attached to the headphones I use for phone calls and I see no difference in usability from previous generations of iPhone. For music listening, I am not listening straight out of the iPhone, analog or otherwise, so no change there.
In terms of CCK bypassing cables being risky, sure Apple may brick it when iOS 11 comes. The cable costs $11. If I have to replace it once a year, that's not much of loss for me. Others may see it differently. If you want a more permanent cable that Apple won't brick, there are cables that are made using authentic chips from the CCK. So, there are options to use the iPhone. Of course, people can also go with Android phones as an alternative, but there are compromises to make there too.