He wrote: "The noise canceling was excellent, almost as good as the Bose QC25.".
Which part of "almost" did you miss?
By the way, there is a difference in how someone like Tyll can listen to headphones, having tested (and I mean TESTED, also with objective instrument measurements) and anyway surely listened to as many Headphones as you cannot even dream of, or how you can.
And, he's got his style, and his preferences. The fact that he affirms that the MEElectronics Air Fi Matrix 2 are the ones to go, and he prefers their sound to the M2, reveals which kind of ideology of sound and preferences/tastes he has got. Which is his right, as much as you have the right to have your tastes.
I personally have another ideology and I consider the Matrix 2 a sub-paar headphones because it cannot produce a realistic amount of bass and as soon as you boost them they distort very badly, which means, yes, out of the box they are balanced as most reviewers like (which is another thing I disagree with, as I consider the uncoloured signature NOT objectively better than the slightly coloured one), but it can please ONLY those people. As soon as anybody wants more warmth or bass, they have no flexibility.
While other headphones can be retuned much more with an EQ and adapt to the tastes of many more people, and I prefer them, even if out of the box they may sound more coloured, at least till this clour is not extreme.
But Tyll is very far from being an idiot.
One thing is David of Cnet rating the ****ty Beats Studio Wireless 4 stars and the good Plantronics Backbeat Pro 3.5, and putting the Beats in a list of the Best headphones in the word, mixed with Beyerdynamics, HiFiman, Audeze etc. THIS is idiot.
But what Tyll does is something else.
By the way, he did NOT say that the Bose sound always better. He said they sound a BIT better with noise cancelling active, while the Momentum sound better in passive mode.
When HE talks of better, he talks of the overall sound QUALITY (detail, transparence, etc) and of a balanced, flat sound signature.
Most consumers do not want a flat signature, they find it boring. I find it boring too. But, reviewers are reviewers.
It took me testing more than 30 BT Headphones to understand some things a bit more.
So, watch your tongue
He said it, in passive mode the Momentum win. In Active, he finds the Bose a bit better. I wrote above the reasons I think he may be saying so.
If you try the MEElectronics Matrix 2 you will understand more about him.