Its emotional more than technical, my hd800/T1/LCD-2 all sounded better from a technical perspective, but frankly its more of a feeling that i got from the HD650 than anything else.
Put it this way, i've really liked a lot of headphones, but i've always missed the HD650's when listening to the higher tier cans, the only pair that didn't make me feel that way were my LCD-2's, and i needed to sell them because i was in a bit of financial trouble, so i've repurchased the HD650.
Sorry for not being very descriptive in this, by the way
+1 I can't explain it in technical aspects/terms either but I've owned the T1 (twice), LCD-2 & HD800 (thrice). I still own the 3rd pair of HD800 but I prefer the HD650 to the T1 & LCD-2 (the latter I did not like at all.) There are IMO many variables that may explain this. The quality of : source, recording/production, the way you hear, sound preference e.g. bass, treble, etc., the amp one uses e.g. tube, SS, balanced, SE, lower or higher quality, etc.
Overall since I've been in this hobby for approx. 6 yrs now, I prefer the Senns HD6xx siblings & the HD800 over the many other HPs I've owned ... so far. Using the same equipment at different times I'll prefer one over the other depending on the music/recordings & probably my overall mood at that moment. That's the best way I can explain it also since I'm not technically savvy or I should say I am technically deficient and although I've tried understanding (& aprreciate) the technical aspects, measurement, charts, etc. posted by different members, I can't for the love of me understand any of that stuff.