Well said! Differences in HRTF are hard to overstate too, and take much of the blame here. Where a treble spike lies for one person could be perfectly in line with the ear gain of another, and vice versa. That’ll throw off (or “on”) the timbre of an instrument pretty easily. I’ve heard other audiophiles/musicians claim that so-and-so headphone has a lifelike timbre for such-and-such instrument. And when I’d heard it, I just couldn’t fathom how. But it does seem to one of those things the HD 600’s are known for.For some reason, some audiophiles believe that musicians have poor headphone/earphones taste. Others also seem to think they know the instruments we play better than ourselves. Fact is that we all like what we like, and that is fine. I know which headphones sound life-like (indeed the HD600 has a natural tonality.)
Oh yeah, calling a violin smooth is definitely true of certain players and certain orchestras (from a certain distance), but equally not of many! It’s a little like people saying classical music is “relaxing.” I’m happy they find a way to relax, but I kinda want to bring them to a Mahler symphony and slap their ears around a little.A well-regarded, now retired audiophile once described a violin's sound as "smooth", but it is nothing of the sort for most violins. Good, powerful violins have certain edgy sound even with good gut strings. Smoothness can be preferred, but often is not clear/projecting enough. So I forgave his opinion as well-meaning, biased ignorance. But the point stands, some audiophiles appear to think they have "chosen ears" to distinguish between "right and wrong" (tonality.) There is much more to headphones than a frequency response graph, useful as those can be. The HD600 sounds both speaker and "instrument like," as you suggested, even if their measurements are not "in" as per the latest flavor of the month. Cymbals decay naturally despite supposedly "lacking extension," and even the bass sounds perfectly normal, as it would in real life! Incredibly well-balanced and natural, amazing product.