Review: Portable amp roundup! 56 portable amps reviewed and compared - FINAL update 12-20-10 added RSA SR-71B
Oct 7, 2009 at 4:20 PM Post #2,447 of 3,234
Visely HEA-4
Info: visely.com (supposedly, although I cannot get that website to work)
Also: Welcome to Audiophilechina

I was asked to review a new Visely amp, the HEA-4. This is a bigger amp than the previously reviewed Visely. It has an internal rechargeable battery. Said battery was loose and floating around inside the chassis when the amp arrived to me from China – so it may be that a little better glue should be used in the manufacturing process. However, the battery was connected, and the amp was unharmed.

Build Quality: B+: very attractive, solid build on the exterior, but points were subtracted for the loose battery. Many other amps have made it to me without such a problem.
Treble: A-: Nice and smooth, and fairly neutral and transparent. Perhaps a bit soft, and lacking the very last bit of top end extension. Still very nice. Never biting or in any way harsh, and with some nice detail and nuance.
Midrange: A-: Quite good performance in the midrange. Fairly open and smooth. Female vocals like on “Tonight We Ride” from Jennifer O’Connor’s “Over the Mountain” were engaging and enjoyable. The mids were not on the same level as any of my three reference amps though – the Meier Move, RSA P-51, and iQube all have more nuanced and transparent mids than the HEA-4.
Bass: B+: Bass was fine, and basically neutral, but it was a little loose at times. All of my reference amps offer better bass control, and a little more definition. They all also offered better extension. This was not a real strength for the Visely, but it was not bad.
Neutrality: A-: It’s just a touch forward in the mids and rolled off on top compared to truly neutral. But it was not that far off.
Soundstaging: B+: Soundstage width was excellent. Image specificity was very good. Depth was just good – soundstage depth was shallower than the reference amps by a notable margin. For example, “Too Much Space” by Lisa Germano has a very nice depth to the recording that I really felt was lacking on the HEA-4.
Transparency: A-: Definitely an open, clear, generally clean, grain-free sound. Not the LAST word in resolution, but still very good. Again, however, not in the league of the reference amps.

The HEA-4 is a pretty decent little amp, competent, but not impressive, and the world of portable amps is pretty full of amps that are impressive. The price of $149 is attractive, though, and for the money, reasonably good performance. Nothing earth-shattering here, however. The portable amp field is very crowded, and the HEA-4 doesn’t really stand out.



Revised Rankings (10-7-09)


OK, so now it’s now 48 amps! Here is my view on how the amps stacked up. Note that the sum of the "Grades" I give does not always tell the whole story in how I rank them, since the whole is sometimes greater or lesser than the sum of the parts, and I am often forced to split hairs here, since the list has gotten so long. Also please note that even if these amps include a DAC, that DAC performance was NOT a factor in these rankings AT ALL. Also, for clarification, this ranking is based on sound quality ONLY, and does not take things like size or battery life into account.

1. Triad Audio Lisa III @ $600.00; Power supply is $350 additional
2. Qables iQube @ $605.00
2. RSA Mustang P-51 (review here) @ $375.00
2. Larocco Audio Pocket Reference II mk 2 (availability unknown - PLEASE read entire review)
3. Headamp Pico @ $349.00
3. Meier Audio 2MOVE (and the older MOVE) (3MOVE @ $270.00)
4. RSA SR71 @ $395.00
4. RSA The Predator @ $475.00
5. RSA The Hornet “M” @ $370.00
5. Decware Zenhead @ $295.00
6. Xenos 1HA-EPC (discontinued)
7. RSA Tomahawk @ $295.00
7. Meier Audio XXS / Headsix @ $166.00/187.00
8. TTVJ Portable Millet Hybrid @ $459.00
8. iBasso D3 Python $219.00 (review here)
9. Xin Reference @ $279.99
9. Meier Audio Porta Corda III (discontinued)
9. Xin SuperMicro IV (current version auditioned 1/22/08) @ $199.99
10. ALO Double Mini3 (review here) @ $235.00
10. Headamp AE-2 @ $349.00
10. Graham Slee Voyager @ $233.00 + S&H from UK
11. iBasso D2 Boa $165.00 (review here)
11. Go-Vibe 7
11. Mini3 (Price depends on build) built @ $125.00
12. Leckerton Audio UHA-3 @ $189.00
13. Portaphile V2^2 @ $275.00
14. mSeed Spirit (discontinued)
14. Mini-Box E @ $229.00
15. Storm 3 (NOT B3) (review here)
15. Storm Little-2 (review here)
15. Storm B4
16. Visely HEA-4 @ $149.00
16. iBasso P-1 (discontinued)
17. Visely HEA- 1 @ $135.00
18. Microshar uAmp107 @ $135.00
18. Practical Devices XM4 @ $135.00
18. C&C XO @ $209.00
19 Music Max LT1 $99 (Review here)
19. iBasso T2 (T4@ $109.00)
20. NuForce $99 (review here)
20. Go-Vibe 6 (discontinued)
21. Xtra X-1 Pro @ $104.00
22. Xenos 0HA-REP (discontinued)
22. iBasso T1 (discontinued)
23. Xtra X-1 (discontinued)
24. C&C Box V2
25. Storm B3
25. Little Dot Micro+ (discontinued)
 
Oct 11, 2009 at 1:02 PM Post #2,449 of 3,234
Seriously with this amount of work this post should be made as sticky so people can refer them first.

This should save a lot of people from posting questions if they click on this FIRST.

/salute
 
Oct 11, 2009 at 1:03 PM Post #2,450 of 3,234
Seriously with this amount of work this post should be made as sticky so people can refer them first.

This should save a lot of people from posting questions if they click on this FIRST.

/salute
 
Oct 31, 2009 at 5:31 PM Post #2,453 of 3,234
Quote:

Originally Posted by rmap /img/forum/go_quote.gif
This is a great comparison. Any plan to review the new RSA Shadow?


Until he does, just look at the P-51 review, since I feel the two amps are siblings and sound very similar.
 
Nov 1, 2009 at 12:48 AM Post #2,454 of 3,234
I have read and re-read Skylabs initial review, and the 3Move stands out as sensational VFM compared to many of the other amps in the top ten. I know that a single Head-Fiers rankings will be subject to debate, but Skylab's thoughts on the Corda mirror many elsewhere. If I could find a good portable that would take the analog out from my Topaz, I would probably go with that, but right now it looks like the 3Move is the next piece of kit at Casa Estreeter.

Thanks again for the fantastic effort you have put into this, skylab.
 
Nov 1, 2009 at 2:34 PM Post #2,455 of 3,234
Quote:

Originally Posted by HeadphoneAddict /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Until he does, just look at the P-51 review, since I feel the two amps are siblings and sound very similar.


Actually it is due to this that I do not plan to review the Shadow. It's not different enough from the P-51 to warrant the effort - if I understand it correctly, it's basically just a low-gain-only P-51 with a digital volume control.
 
Nov 1, 2009 at 8:25 PM Post #2,456 of 3,234
Quote:

Originally Posted by Skylab /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Actually it is due to this that I do not plan to review the Shadow. It's not different enough from the P-51 to warrant the effort - if I understand it correctly, it's basically just a low-gain-only P-51 with a digital volume control.


I was talking to Ray yesterday and he says they are a little different inside, and he does think they sound a little different. To my ears they were both equally as good, even if I didn't have time to listen for the small differences. I heard the Shadow at CanJam with my ES3X, and also at the July CO meet listening via Sony R10 and Lawton Audio modded Denon D7000.

Jamato8 can better speak of the small differences, as he has been using a prototype Shadow for a while and owns a P-51. For me, the P-51 s still my best portable amp, and Naamanf actually liked it a little more than my $995 ALO Amphora.
 
Nov 1, 2009 at 9:06 PM Post #2,457 of 3,234
How about adding the Pico slim, and the ALO Rx to the portable list?
 
Nov 1, 2009 at 9:27 PM Post #2,459 of 3,234
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lil' Knight /img/forum/go_quote.gif
How can one review an amp that even hasn't been released yet?


Cut him some slack, he lists his location as "under a rock".
 
Nov 1, 2009 at 10:01 PM Post #2,460 of 3,234
Planning to add to the list, seeing as the slim will be out very soon, good enough?... good grief this place is ridiculous sometimes.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top