canali
Headphoneus Supremus
- Joined
- Jun 25, 2003
- Posts
- 2,821
- Likes
- 444
IDK. I call everything you stick between a computer and a DAC a "magic box", that's how little love I have for those band aid solutions. there isn't one of those products that couldn't be integrated into a DAC, so if I go with the axiom that DAC engineers aren't idiots. if such solution had universal benefit, they would use it in their products right? like galvanized stuff, external power supply, reclocking, noise filtering attempts etc etc. all could help for some problems or not(some might actually degrade the fidelity in some cases). so overall, I go with the idea that if a DAC needs one of those stuff to perform well, and it doesn't have it, then maybe the guy who made the DAC wasn't all that good.
that's how I think, I would sooner change my DAC, or maybe if the computer was really super sucky, get a new usb card or get into a solution that doesn't use USB(optical?), than buy those usb add-ons(and I posted the same kind of rant on the wyrd's topic and a few others, I'm not focused on this little guy, I really just dislike them all ^_^).
now just like the wyrd, and other stuff, it's perfectly possible to have one such DAC that I would judge defective with average to poor USB, and get a real improvement with a magic box. so is it still snake oil when it does help a few guys? I don't feel that way. to me snake oil is a placebo and never does anything.
the main problem with those products is how much the general information we get can be divorced from the possible impacts it would have on most systems. when a car has a tire problem, the repair guy will surely try to sell you a lot of useless replacements, but he won't start telling you to add 4 more tires because the car will work better with 8 wheels, or a second oil tank. nobody works like that, we look for the problem and we replace the defective part. only when people absolutely refuse to change their system even though it has problems, should they maybe look into band aids. that's when those products make the most sens IMO. but they're at best solutions for specific problems, not magical sound upgrading boxes. that much is sure.
maybe people are to blame for so often seeking solutions to problems they don't have? ^_^
and i think this is a very interesting area, given we're all into wanting music to sound better.
castleofargh: does your op/analysis (if i read it correctly) equally apply to the
iF purfier
...or to the usb retrogen?
http://uptoneaudio.com/products/usb-regen
http://uptoneaudio.com/pages/j-swenson-tech-corner
it gets confusing because you also get respectable reviewers giving positive reviews of these products.
Darko, for instance, seems to feel some of these conditioners can make somewhat of a difference:
http://www.digitalaudioreview.net/2015/05/on-the-road-with-the-audioquest-jitterbug/
http://www.digitalaudioreview.net/2015/11/from-earth-to-jupiter-ifi-ipurifier-takes-usb-audio-further/
excerpt:
The iPurifier will (more likely than not) improve the sound of your digital audio system in almost every respect: more resolving, wider and deeper soundstage, airy on good quality records. That sums to greater emotional wallop and more comfort. I remain astonished by one human being’s genius to create such miniature thing with an ability to change the sound to such a degree. Highly recommended, especially for use in an entry-level system between DAC and computer! Worth the US$99? You know it.
http://www.digitalaudioreview.net/2015/05/on-the-road-with-the-audioquest-jitterbug/
excerpt:
The tiny JitterBug ain’t full o’ *****:
it brings greater vivacity to the midrange, improves on the Astell&Kern’s already respectable talents with separation, most notably cleaving more space around bass notes that now go deeper. Simply put: music played via the AK120 II sounds both more spirited and less synthetic when JitterBugged.
I’ve encountered improvements of a similar nature when reviewing LessLoss DFPC power cables, iFi’s USB power filter and Antipodes Audio music servers. Removing electrical noise makes music sound more natural, more believable.
The magnitude of the JitterBug’s enrichment is comparable to adding Amarra (US$35+) or Audirvana+ (US$74) to iTunes or having an m2Tech hiFace 2 (US$219) intercede between computer USB output and DAC coaxial input. JitterBug’s pricing here is keener still.
In fact, I’ve heard DAC deltas smaller than those heard between the AK120 II with and without JitterBug – yes, the message here is that simple and at a the US$49 asking, the risks of buy-before-you-try are suitably low.
again, i'm no techie, just trying to figure it all out: balancing manufacturer claims against people who've used/critiqued them.