GreenBow
Headphoneus Supremus
- Joined
- Feb 6, 2015
- Posts
- 4,204
- Likes
- 1,608
I think the idea of stacking the TT, M Scaler and TToby is great in terms of looks and design but it isn't something I'd ever considered in terms of sound quality. Cable management, RF/electronic noise and heat. I've always given plenty of space between pieces of hardware... probably a habit from using Naim... always provide space between each box and the M scaler (a computer) is placed as far away from the DAC as possible.
I used to have a Naim Supernait 2 integrated amp with a HiCap DR power supply. The SN3 is an improvement but from all accounts, not a massive one. It's the top of the line integrated that Naim sell and I can say without doubt, the TT2 directly into speakers is significantly different. I say different, whether it's better will depend on what you like. If you like transparency, natural presentation with large soundstage with bags of detail then it is a definite improvement. However, part of the draw of Naim is the, "Naim Sound". And rightly so, they are great amps.
To me, the mids on the Naim SN2 have a lot more bass, more warmth when compared to the TT2 driving speakers directly. After comparing the two, I felt they were too heavy and masked too much detail for me. A cliche I know but it was like a veil being lifted across the mds. Suddenly I could hear loads of detail in the mids that I hadn't heard before. After a week I couldn't go back and that's when the SN2, HiCap and ND5 XS2 went up for sale and in came the M Scaler.
So, given the improvement going from M Scaler - TT2 direct to then adding the Etude, I can say for sure I would never find a Naim integrated, SN2 or 3, to be better than the Etude when combined with a TT2 and M Scaler. But, if you like the Naim sound then you may not agree and find the Chord setup to analytical due to the lack of extra weight in the mids and all that extra detail. Horses for courses.
I think there are a few others over at Naim arranging a demo of the Etude so it will be interesting to hear their take on it as well.
Ultimately, whether it's Naim, Chord or Hegel etc it's about getting the right, closest mix of source, DAC, amp and speakers that works in your room and satisfies your taste in how music is presented and then complete the fine tuning with cables. We all have the same destination, our version of perfection, just that we all take a different route![]()
That's a great post; totally informative.
Your comments about the Naim sound are fully interesting, because I have never heard Naim. However a while ago when I was pondering Ttoby vs Naim SN3, and ended up trying Ttoby. I am, and at the time was hesitant about Naim. Going by reviews alone and impressions, I figured the Chord amplifier sound would be more neutral across all respects. (Not just tonal balance.) At the time I was leaning towards an integrated amplifier, but went with trying Ttoby for sound. I think I worried that the naim SN3 might be a bit thick and mask some detail. Whereas reviews of Chord amps made me think they were detailed, neutral, tonally accurate, fleet-footed, and turned corners instantly. Ttoby reviews were stand-out excellent too, while Naim SN3 reviews are a brilliant but a little mixed.
I know we must judge ourselves, as synergy plays a part. However with the virus, going anywhere is a risk. Hence I read reviews, let them sink in, then read them again. Think of questions and read the reviews again and again. Anon.
Anyway, I have been reading the Naim thread that you linked. I am reading where and you have been describing TT2 driving speakers. When I read your first impressions I worried, because you said it sounded bright and thin. ... However I totally agree with you. That is exactly what I heard initially. Or until I adjusted to it.
My experience with Chord DACs though made me stick with it. Initially I had Meridian Explorer hooked on to my PC for sound. Then I tried Mojo. To me Mojo sounded thin, metallic, and bright. It sounded more detailed though, so I sort of figured keep going. After maybe a week I realised that it sounded so smooth compared to anything before it. Smooth not because it was a fat warm sound; smooth because it wasn't full of distortions. After ten days I was hearing how it was actually a natural warm sounding DAC too. It was all uphill from there.
When I got Hugo 2, it sounded bright with shards of new detail all over the place, on familiar music. I focused on 'how warm is it - and perceived natural warmth'. Long story short, I gave it time and adjusted, and fell hopelessly in love with it. ... When I got TT2 it took a few days to adjust. Then of course going TT2 driving speakers it too time to adjust. Once adjusted though, and it's something else. Smooth, natural warmth, solid sounding, and mountains of detail. Just took time to put it all in place and hear it as a whole.
It's good to hear you had the same thing when moving to TT2 driving speakers. As some report no adjustment. Maybe it's down to the amplifier previously used. Of course TT2 has headphone socket, and remembers headphone levels separately from rear ports. Win - win really.
(Am suspecting Hegel H120 will have a similar signature to Chord Ttoby. In integrated form though.)
Last edited: