Hey guys, for the last couple months a lot of you guys have been PM'ing me about the cap mod. I think I'm the first one to do it, so I'll just move what I wrote from the original post to here. FYI: You only need a solder gun for this mod, and of course the caps.
0. Panasonic FM 25V 470uF aka stock caps
Panasonic caps are known to have unbeatable specs. Uber-low ESR and extremely high ripple current makes it an excellent choice for budget-conscious DIYers. They adds very little coloration and sounds reasonably good. On top of that, it only costs $0.3 a piece. Headamp likely used these caps to save cost.
1. Nichicon FW 25V 470uF
These golden caps are the go-to for many audio companies. With gold-sleevings, they are very good-looking, have extremely low ESR and high ripple.
Replacing the FM caps with these yield a very audible improvement. The first thing you'll notice is how the sound opens up as if you open up the window for a breath of fresh air. Everything suddenly sounds so transparent you'll have a hard time beliving its the same amp. Soundstage extends wider, bass goes deeper and treble gains more fienesse. No downsides I can speak of. Nada.
2. Nichicon KW 25V 2200uF
If I were to judge these caps based on the looks, they'd score higher than ELNA.
Given how satisfied I am with the FWs, KW seems like the next logical step. For those of you who don't know what to look for in a power supply cap replacement, the rule of thumb is bigger is better. Bigger power supply cap can store more power and more importantly have less low-frequency roll-off, which is why I bumped up the cap value to 2200uF in hope of improving bass response. (more about capacitance and low-frequency roll-off can be found here:
https://www.diyaudio.com/forums/par...-capacitors-shootout-coupling-headphones.html)
Nichicon markets KW as a step up from the FWs, they're twice as expensive and have black sleeving instead of gold. So it should be better, right?
Wrong. I desoldered FWs and put these KWs in preparing to be wowed, and what I got was a lifeless sound muddy beyond redemption. These KWs are easily the worst sounding caps I've ever put into the GLs. I gave them 2 weeks to settle down, and in the end its still the same muddy sound with a very closed-in soundstage and no instrument separation to speak of.
I don't know why Nichicon would market these as the better cap. They cost twice as much as the FWs, aren't as good looking and sound so much worse.
3. Nichicon Fine Gold 25V 470uF
I've used Fine Gold for recapping amps in the past and am very satisfied with their performance. They're the second-best audio cap in Nichicon's line-up and projects a very transparent sound with very little coloration. Replacing the KWs with FGs is more than just a breath of fresh air----they're a total revelation. All of a sudden you hear details that you can never hear before and everything sounds crystal clear. These are the logical step up from FWs and indeed sound better, but the downside is they're bigger and heavier. Fitting them on the PCB proves to be quite a struggle.
4. Nichicon KZ 25V 470uF
Two weeks in with the Fine Golds and my hands got itchy again. KZs are the best caps Nichicon's ever made. They're even bigger than FGs and absolutely dwarfs the FWs. There's no way I can actually fit one of these in the tiny PCB of Gilmore Lite MkII. But there's always a nagging voice in the back of my mind. What if it sounds better? And what if I try really hard?
Well I did manage to fit these in in the end, at the cost of 6 hours, a lot of sweat, and bent capacitor legs. There's no way I'm doing this ever again.
And how does it sound? Sublime! These have a wider soundstage than the Fine Golds and are a bit more open sounding. They are hands down the least colored caps I've used on the Gilmore. Nothing really gets in the way between you and your music. Measurements of this cap is rock solid and if all you want is transparency, this is the cap to go, given that you can fit one of these ginormous beast in whatever PCBs you fancy.
5. ELNA Silmic II 16V 470uF
ELNA, a household name if your into capacitors. Nelson Pass loves them and touted them as the best sounding cap beside Black Gate. I have the exact same experiences from re-capping my vintage amps and other headphone amps like the rHead and Jazz FF. These badboys are ginormous, but if you can fit one of these in, chances are you won't replace them ever again. They wipe the floor with everything else.
But the problem is they're just too big. With a diameter of 16mm and lead spacing of 7.5mm, there's no way I can cram these in without damaging the PCB. And its not until 3 weeks into KZs that a thought suddenly occured to me: the Gilmore Lite uses a +-15V power supply which in theory sums up to 30V. How are they using 25V caps then???
With this thought I measured the voltage across each capacitor with my multimeter, and to my great surprise the voltage across each cap is actually 15V instead of 30V. As it turns out, the folks at HeadAmp are a little too conservative and opted for 25V caps when its not necessary.
Which means I can use 16V caps.
And 16V 470uF Silmic II actually fits. 12mm diameter, 5.0mm lead spacing. PERFECT.
With the enthusiasm of a new born child, I ordered 4 16V 470uF Silmic IIs and replaced the KZs with these. It was midnight when I finished the solderjob, and when I first powered these on I near had an orgasm.
Is it really a $500 amp I'm hearing?
The change is so radical that I can hardly call it an upgrade. While there is soundstage and imaging before, the sound now gains a new dimension, being infinitely smooth and tube-like. There is zero harshness to be found. The bass digs extremely deep without being obtrusive, and the mids is the smoothest, most lifelike I've ever heard out of a solid-state. Someone once commented that the Silmic II imbues music with a tube-like warmth and smoothness (
https://audiokarma.org/forums/index.php?threads/electrolytic-capacitor-shoot-out.381961/page-5), and its absolutely true. Music comes out and greet you. It envelops you, hugs you, giving you warm tingles all over your body.
Theses caps are dangerously addictive, to the point that I find myself spending less time on Head-Fi and more time actually listening to music. They are every bit as transparent as the KZs and resolve details at least as well as the FGs. The biggest difference being that it imbues music with a tube-like quality and smoothness. Everything sounds seductive. You'd find yourself tapping your toes to the music and going from one song to another. Time and space is lost, only you and your music remains.
On top of all that, these are also the only caps capable of transforming the Gilmore into a much more expensive-sounding amp. While the KZ, FG and FWs are all worthy of being called an upgrade, they're ultimately only upgrades. The ELNAs transform this amp into something else. They sound tonally rich much like a tube amp, but with the precision and separation of a solid-state. And this is the area where the ELNAs had the Nichicons handily beat---the Nichicons sounds sterile and thin while the ELNAs sound harmonically rich and emotionally charged. If I were to blindly guess how much this amp costs based on sound alone, I'd probably say $2000.
A few things I found out later: Panasonic has a general series capacitor called M. Not FM, just M. And they're rated at 85C. These caps are surprisingly good for the money. They sound much better than the FC cap these amp comes with.
Also a general rule of thumb doing the cap mod: You shouldn't keep soldering and de-soldering just to try different caps. PCBs can easily get damaged if your soldering iron stays on a joint for too long. For this purpose you should get some good solder, preferably cardas solder. They flow extremely well, and are the only solder that doesn't require any flux paste to de-solder. All in all they're extremely easy to work with.
IF you REALLY want to catch em all and just get your hands on every cap out there, try this. After removing the capacitor, clean the two leg holes and solder two wires in place of the capacitor. Ta da! You get a free capacitor extension! Any cap you want to try just solder it to the other end of the wire. This way you would never risk damaging the PCB. A friend of mine was crazy enough to cram four snap-in capacitors inside the little Gilmore, thanks to this mod. Generally for capacitors of the same rating, the bigger the better. So if you really want to go all out, check out Nichicon's Super Through or ELNA's LAO. These uglyass MFs sound out of this world, but you do have to find some innovative ways to keep them inside the tight board space.