A Newbie’s Perspective:
I certainly appreciate all the expertise on this site. I’ve really been learning quite a bit. My knowledge and expertise is limited to comfort, how good I personally think my music sounds through the headphones, and user experience— how easy they headphones are to use.
I got the Clear MGs and Celestee earlier this year and I love them. Based on this site and other sources I run them through good DACs into my phone or computer, or I run them straight into an A&K Kann Max. I also got a several IEMs for traveling around. I qualify this just to say I have a newbie’s level of dangerous experience.
But I missed the convenience of grab and go that I have with BT head phones. With the Bathys and and PX8, I saw a great opportunity. I got both to see which I like best.
For me, the Bathys wins all day in the comfort category. The PX8s get warm around my ears and I have to take a break. But the Bathys can stay on all day (all flight) happily. I love the pads, although the MGs are still the most comfortable set ever for me… for me they are the standard.
In terms of sound… it depends what I listen to. Jazz trios and orchestral music recorded more recently, sound better to me on the Bathys. I don’t know why… just that they do. The level of detail is immersive and I can easily get lost. But, I prefer older recordings on the PX8. Again… not sure why. From a rock perspective, Cheap Trick… my favorite band, is incredible on the PX8. Less exciting on the Bathys. Jazz vocals from women, overall, to me, sound better on the Bathys, but I prefer Kurt Elling on the PX8.
![Man shrugging :man_shrugging: 🤷♂️](https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/joypixels/assets/8.0/png/unicode/64/1f937-2642.png)
So, from a sound basis, it is a toss up for me.
User experience… the ergonomics of the PX8 is just intuitive and great for me. But, for some reason, they default to only connecting to the previous source, even when I set up the source to automatically detect. The Bathys UX is less iser friendly and I’m always feeling around for the controls. But they connect to all devices easily and I can go back and forth without effort. Of course, I’m sure others have had the opposite experience, so user error may be the culprit.
My wife is probably going to kill me… in which case you can all tell her I promised them to you upon my death… but I’m going to keep them both. I think the Bathys has a slight edge, but that may change over time. And of course, your mileage may vary.