When a product is worthy, it warrants the "cheerleading". Most folks try to read past that, and cut to what matters most to them as a reader. There is always going to be hype for new products, nature of this beast. Hype train, as it is called. It is irresponsible shopping to buy based on one opinion.Hey I completely get you, and have total respect for what you guys do! Without you this hobby would be stillborn - I wish we had people like you where I live.
My comment was more tongue-in-cheek, wasn't looking to offend, so apologies if I did. I will say I dislike OTT hype about as much as I dislike.inaccurate and unfounded criticism. I get that new products are a labour of love for many, but when it comes to offering critical advice for hardworking people, there comes a point where comments from experienced users need to be more responsible than "oh this is just amazing guys, buy it!"
I think if you read @aminus's comments he was actually quite complementary of Odin, and although he came down on some of the others, I get why. But his is a particular type of review, and at least it's backed up by experience, thought and music examples. For me as a consumer, his type of review is more useful than the cheerleading that goes hand in hand with a new product launch.
Just my opinion, of course.
I am not picking on any one or their review style, in this instance. I will say, that going against "the grain" sells for certain individuals. Look at your nightly news, if it isn't negative, it isn't going to be on there, it's what sells. To have a different style stands out from the rest. If that type of writing checks your boxes, read it. Everyone is free to read what they wish. Anyone that posts their dialogue about an item knows that eventually it will make it's way to the brand thread.
This is a hobby to me, nothing more. Lots of people disagree with me and I certainly disagree with lots of people. My existence in this hobby is controversial to some but that it is not going to thwart my ability to write my opinion or call anyone out that I don't agree with as well. If you are publishing something, you need to have thick skin and be open to critique, that applies to anyone that publishes, myself included. The internet is quite large and there is plenty of room for everyone's opinion.
My style is to spend time with something, before writing about it, and yes it does require funds to do that, maybe I am fortunate to be able to do that. I know I take a significant loss each time I sell something. Everyone has a different style.
It is the same criticism of cellphone reviews and their battery life. Most of the reviewers have the phone for a week and write about battery life. I do agree, you can formulate an "opinion" in that time, but it can't be taken as gospel. Android and manufacturer software is developed to learn your habits and adjust accordingly over time. Time, being the operative word here.
There are a lot of factors to how "experienced" an experienced user is. After all, every one who writes anything is "subjective". It is all opinion and conjecture. The facts involved are the specs, and what you receive in a package with your purchase. Beyond that, if I say there is lift in the upper mid-range, that's how I hear it and when I publish that, I open myself up to debate.
As far as Empire Ears "freshening up" their existing lineup, that is their business decision and they see a need. It appears they aren't touching one of their biggest sellers, the Legend X. I would like to hear the revisions for my own curiosity, not necessarily to write about them.
With regards hype train, it is great to have new options and exciting for the developer and consumer alike.
I would love to hear Hero, sounds like an interesting signature that is market priced.
ODIN is a very good IEM. The signature won't agree with everyone, but of course there are factors to that. No IEM agrees with everyone. Maybe it just isn't your signature, maybe it is a quick listen, maybe it hasn't been seasoned, whatever it is, it just isn't for you. For the folks that try it and love it, they will hype it. A little positivity in this world with it's current state of affairs is not a bad thing.
I notice some things about the ODIN signature the more I listen to it, and that is daily. I will touch on all points, positive and negative, in my review. The positives do outweigh the negatives, forgive me if that is feeding the hype.