Fair assessment.
I’ve read some that love him yet describe him as “tough” and exacting while others call him “bully.”
I just read that the British music magazine Gramophone also noted that Barenboim has been awarded Honorary Conductor by the BPO and there was even a quote from one of the members of the orchestra lauding Barenboim nor only for his great musicianship but also regarding him as a friend.
A couple of nights ago there was a documentary on Swedish televison about the singer Cecilia Bartoli and Barenboim was featured as one of her early mentors going back to 1987 and judging from the documentary they seem to get along very well after all these years.
Talking big names in music, Barenboim mentioned that not long after his discovering Bartoli Herbert von Karajan called him on the phone and asked Barenboim about her.
He even admitted that he was not used to talking with Karajan on the phone.
As a photographer I have been to quite a few rehearsals and recording sessions with some famous conductors ,and I have met and photographed a few of the big names and yes without mentioning any names they can be be both vain, temperamental and not always easy.
During rehearsals tensions can sometimes be high.
But in my experience the tempers I have seen fly under such conditions have mainly been in the interest of the music as the conductor saw it.
But there have been situations where the conductor was wrong as well.
Barenboim I have only talked to in person once in a record shop many years ago.
And in a for him maybe a bit embarrassing situation.
But I have respect and admiration for the results he is getting not only as a conductor but also as a pianist. A musician who has got all the 32 Beethoven Piano Sonatas under his fingers and can play them all superbly well from memory I have great respect for as a musician.
And Karajan so disliked by many today was imho judging from the couple of live concerts I saw him conduct and the MANY recordings I still like, was also a GREAT musician and conductor, I think.
Maybe a Karajan quote might help explaining why some collegues have problems with Barenboim?
Karajan once responded in an interview when he had been accused of Elitism.
"I am not an Elitist I am a Super Elitist"
When you strive really high not everyone will be able to follow you all the way. And those who fail to do so may feel personally hurt and resentful, when in fact and musical terms,it was maybe they themselves who where not capable enough?
Or maybe he is sometimes just in a bad mood and lets that spill out over his colleagues?
I have seen such things too behind the scenes.
Whatever the case with Barenboim he is at the helm of both a Berlin Orchestra and leading an Opera House and Honorary Conductor of a third in the musical capital of Germany and those are facts.
Cheers CC