daberti
100+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2015
- Posts
- 295
- Likes
- 52
Why does it matter if DSD is converted to PCM if its done correctly? They are just two different ways of representing the same digital data, the content would be identical.
Because there is actually a lot of confusion already: NOS Dacs, OS DACs, true multibit DACs and so on with an endless list......all claiming to be THE correct implementation.
Truth to be told advantages stand on each side, as caveats.
So it looks the truth stands in how each DAC deals in the most efficiently way with the latters, given the initial choice.
I'm NOT quite in the mood of going thru' the burden of explaining the differences about DSD natively recorded (one take, no DSP) as such and DSD as transcoded from i.e. DXD just to mention one.
Neither I'll make the mistake of saying that DSD is best than PCM or viceversa.
EDIT:
But one thing needs to be stated clearly, to limit reigning confusion: what it is Fully Native DSD.
It is made of what I call 4N requirements (N stands for Native) that all need to be checked.
1)N recording: recording in one take straight to the mixer and from this to the DSD DAW.
2)N decoding by the player: no upsampling, no conversion to PCM.
3)N delivering to DAC: a bitperfect DSD stream is sent to the DAC either the DoP or the ASIO driver way.
4)N DAC DSD Handling: the DAC must NOT convert DSD to PCM. Things get different when we deal with i.e. DACs that convert DSD to PCM for a number of reasons, as digital volume control. These DACs are NOT DSD Native but DSD-capable. They may even deliver better results than the native DSD process itself scores, but we're no longer in Fully Native DSD realm.
I'm NOT saying Mojo, Hugo and Dave are crappy. I would have NOT bought the former two.
Neither I'm saying that in the specific case converting internally DSD to PCM with all the clever measures adopted by Rob brings about worst results.
What I'm saying is that I'd politely like to know -in this very case- if a DAC I purchased (and this historically held true for every single DAC I do own, BTW) handles DSD without any modification or does actually convert it into PCM. If the latter holds true it is NOT a Native DSD DAC.
All that simple
Last edited: