Quote:
I came a cross this a while ago
http://news.discovery.com/human/life/worlds-quietest-room-will-drive-you-crazy-in-30-minutes.htm
What would happen if one would have a speaker setup here?
At first i thought it might be great, no unwanted reflections but then there arent any reflections at all.
I'm not very familiar with ideal speaker placement/room treatment and such, so i'm wondering.
Hi
Stitch,
I have experience of creating a listening room with a lot of audio treatments created by myself. This was some years ago.
It is a common mistake to believe that the ideal room for listening to an audio replay system will have no reflections. This will be a very poor listening room.
The thing to do is to eliminate the vast majority of reflections and then carefully manage a few key reflections.
I have seen the mistake that all reflections are to be removed repeated here in "Sound Science" by people who have never treated a room (obviously) but who believe themselves to be experts
If you are using loudspeakers then treating a room is imho probably the best thing you can do with a view getting good reproduction.
The treatments are extremely intrusive indeed, so you do need a dedicated listening room.
Much of the treatment is concerned with reducing the amount of bass and mid-range energy in the room. This requires a lot of absorbers with a great deal of depth.
I believe that a good budget audio system in a well treated room will sound better than a "hi end" system in a non-treated room.
Hi Fi publications (print and web) don't cover the benefits of treated rooms because it just doesn't fit into the consumerist exercise of just buying things in neat boxes. The Hi Fi interest is unfortunately now just a consumerist exercise unfortunately.
There are some great publications for treating rooms and there is much good information on the web (as long as you avoid the "experts" in these Sound Science forums who have never treated rooms but believe that you must remove all reflections!).
The first port of call is the excellent "Master Handbook of Acoustics" by F. Alton Everest.
Then I suggest some googling.