Duncan, that's a reasonable idea, I think.
But I don't know if I'm crazy about the idea of newbie forums. It seems a bit elitist, not something, I think, that will encourage people to participate. I find many newbies make striking discoveries and contribute in productive and new ways to the forums, making the community richer in many ways. Also, I find that reading a veteran's post on a newbie question changes as the veteran's perspective on his own knowledge changes. It is interesting to see people grow in their understanding, even veterans.
I agree that it would be nice if people educated themselves on the forum and the information a little before they dove in with questions...maybe something like Duncan's idea would work for this?
And I have to say that I don't entirely agree with the idea that there is now a stable community and no really new information out there. There are new products, new music, new ideas, and new presentations of old ideas. Personally, I find the "what's the best pcdp for $100 interesting when it comes up every few months because I like to check out what's new that I might have missed, what people are trying these days, and so on. But in the words of the dude, "that's just like, you know, your opinion man."