leeperry,
I really don't understand what you are trying to say and imply. What you are saying lacks coherence, logic and sense to me.
Here is what makes sense to me : when choosing a usb to spdif converter (which is the topic of this thread), the best one is the one that has the lowest jitter.
The lower the jitter of a transport, the closer you get to the truth. If you don't like the sound of a known low jitter transport (let's say DCS, Esoteric, Accuphase, ...) then the culprit is not the transport but the DAC that is poorly designed.
In order to get the closer to real music, you need a low jitter transport and a transparent DAC. If you start coloring the sound from the very begining (at the transport level) you will loose details and parts of the music that cannot be recovered later in the audio chain.
So I cannot agree with when you suggest to people to use reclock with a built in sound card in a noisy mother board because you think that in your particular case it sounded smoother than something.
Anyway, I will stop arguing with you on this subject unless it is to compare different usb to spdif converters (or PCI cards). If it is just to say that reclock is better ... well don't count me in the discussion.
Quote:
Originally Posted by leeperry /img/forum/go_quote.gif
besides you're only as weak as your weakest link(again) so as you said, CS8414/DIR9001 will react differently..
and I wouldn't get too hung up on the DAC...as the opamps you're using as LPF or I/V on the DAC output will color the sound far more than switching DAC's ever would from what many ppl believe(it's also been my personal experience ): Heres some test results for the new ESI Juli@ card. [3] - RightMark Forums
|
Just for you information, the DAC I am currently using doesn't use a single opamp in the signal path. It is an all discrete design and the filtering after the PCM1704uk (multibit dac chips) is done in the current domain. Then the I/V and buffering are done by mean of high quality vishay resistors and transistors,...
So no I can't hear differences between opamps (they are not used) but I hear differences in the digital filters. I have also a user replaceable digital filter module: I can either use it with the HDCD capable PDM100 or the DF1704 digital filter.
Also you have to understand that the performance of the digital section is not dependant only on the type of DIR used (CS8414 vs. DIR9001). The power supply, ground traces, impedance, quality of the internal wiring, shielding, ... all of that will affect the sound. So even if you have 2 DACs using the same DIR9001+PCM1794+AD797 for example, they can sound completely different. One of them can sound harsh and the other one overly soft depending on the choices of the designer.