StanD
Headphoneus Supremus
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2013
- Posts
- 9,002
- Likes
- 1,134
So I found this Anandtech audio test, and they say: "In our test data, the most powerful phone was the iPhone 5, at 32.46 mW of power. Next is the Nexus 5 at 22.24 mW, though we can’t drive it that high. Then the Note 3 at 11.81 mW and finally the Galaxy S4 at 3.895 mW."
They don't say what load those numbers are into, but just looking at those relative numbers, our different impressions make sense: The Nexus 5 has twice the output power of a Note 3, and more than 5x the power of a Galaxy S4. So I take back what I said: If you're using a Samsung phone with the HD600, you might very well see a significant, not merely audible, difference with the Magni.
I still quibble a bit at "night and day" -- nothing you can do is going to give you the same totally clear, radically different sound signature you'd get from a different headphone -- but yeah, you will almost certainly be much happier with the HD600 with an external amp, rather than straight out of a Samsung phone.
This article states that the tests were done using Apple Earpods, which according to Apple is 23 Ohms so there is a small disconnect to the 32 Ohms examples I'll give below.
Going by the numbers you gave, just 1.5W (Uber at 32 Ohms) is 16.6 dB more power than the iPhone 5, which is significant. 1.5W compared to the Note 3 is 21 dB more power. One should also be aware that our hearing's FR varies with loudness, so at lower volume our perception of bass diminshes as does treble to a lesser degree. All of these power levels will be much lower at 300 Ohms where the power supply rails of a phone pale in comparison to the Magni. The Magni 2 Uber has +/- 16V power rails and 320 mW at 300 Ohms which is more like in the domain of the HD600. Reverse engineering the numbers for the iPhone's power at 23 Ohms, gives 0.864 V which gives 2.5 mW at 300 Ohms. OK, that's some fiddling to get to the numbers.
If I'm right, that gives the Magni a 21 dB advantage at 300 Ohms.