Quote:
Originally Posted by MoonShine /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Science has far more sensitive instruments than the human ear so no: It is not possible to physically hear something that cannot be measured
|
But, as discussed in the last few posts, you need to add:
"that cannot be measured
by some instrument, perhaps an instrument that has never been built, nor conceived of, nor the necessity for even imagined".
You don't want to claim that we know how to measure everything with today's science and instruments, do you? Every such claim in the history of science has come up short later. It is impossible to build a rocket to break the gravitational pull of the earth [common scientific view decades ago]. It is impossible to pack more than n bits on portable media [Polaroid went bankrupt believing there was a fundamental limit on digital storage that would keep instant film developing alive]. There will be no more than a handful of digital computers in the world [common engineering view at one time].
These conclusions are always based on what seems to be air-tight arguments ... until the next breakthru in knowledge.
But that's not my real point -- this is it: if we have finite time, let's measure listeners, and learn how to do that well (it is not easy, I agree). This is a direct, frontal attack on the problem. Engineering bench measurements are a sideways attack on the problem we are trying to solve. They are much easier to do. But it's doing what we
can do rather than something harder, which we
should do.
The builders of equipment need the test instruments and the bench work of course -- they need to do real engineering. But we are consumers. We are trying to find out what sounds good.
In an earlier post I pointed out that the food industry settled this long ago. Food chemistry is used to design the products, but taste tests are used to determine marketability. And these tests -- with millions of dollars on the line -- are always single-blind (taster blind); ours should be single-blind too (listener blind) run by unbiased supervisors ... no matter what The Absolute Sound says!