Learned a valuable lesson today on the power of the mind... I have the Drop 789 (which replaced my Monolith 887 for reasons unrelated to this post) to play with while my HPA4 is built. Last night I was listening to the Abyss on the WA5 and decided to switch to the 789. I become convinced it sounded like crap, compressed and dry. I couldn't shake the feeling after swapping a few times and comparing tracks. I then dragged out an old Violetric and compared the 789, Violectric, and WA5 on my Stellia, and came to the same conclusion -- the 789 sounded bad. Since the HPA4 uses the same THX AAA technology, should I immediately cancel it and look elsewhere?
Well, this morning, I realized I had an old A/B headphone switcher lying around. I couldn't use it with the Abyss but I could with the Stellia so I hooked it up and A/B'd the 789 and the Violectric (obviously both solid-state, so apples to apples). After level-matching by ear I went to get a drink, and in the meantime forgot which was A and B. (Yeah, hardly a scientific test, but trust me, I am VERY forgetful.) I compared a bunch of tracks and decided which position on the switch was my favorite. Guess what, it was the 789. The differences I thought I heard last night disappeared. With the 789 versus the WA5 on the switcher I did prefer the WA5, but I concluded it was due to the WA5's wonderful tube warmth, not because the 789 was any less dynamic.
Going back to the Abyss, without an XLR switcher I couldn't do the same blind-ish comparison between the 789 and the WA5 (my Violectric doesn't speak Abyss). Manually moving the cable and re-comparing tracks, however, I now don't hear what I heard last night. So my order for the HPA4 stands.
Moral of the story: Your brain is a liar.