Quick update on 'Stuttergate' with Sennheiser headphones.
Having returned three pairs of M2 wireless and done some research of other BT models, I decided to give the Sennhesier Urbanite XL wireless a try again. I had purchased these headphones previously, and found the BT stuttering issues to be the same as with the M2 wireless and the sound signature to be less impressive.
In short, I am amazed. This current set Urbanite XL wireless show none of the BT issues I had previously with this line of headphones, or the M2 wireless. That's correct - stutter-free, interference free performance when walking around with the phone in my pocket. Error free when walking in the city, at home, in the park with my dog and on my daily commute by public transport. Just as they should be. And what of the sound quality? Well, coming back to these headphones has been a revelation. There is no ANC to annoy, just good passive noise reduction from the velour ear pads. I really like the sound - it is not as refined or rich as the M2 wireless, but seems tighter and better integrated. Midrange is impressive, and the treble, while a little rolled off, is capable of conveying great detail. Bass hits well, but does not overpower - think the marketing guff about awesome bass is just that. Yes, it's a bit more forward in the mix, but it does not dominate the frequency response nor suck out the midrange. I can do no better to describe the sound than to quote directly from a UK retailer's review:
The bass is very well controlled and clear with plenty of punch; the micro-velour type earpads may soak up a little of the lower sub-bass region but overall the bass impact is very impressive.
Midrange gives a wonderful sense of space and both male and female vocal are well complimented, with reverb/echo easily cutting through. There's next to no clutter here and harmonics shine.
Treble is rolled off slightly; the Urbanite XL Wireless does not hold it back, but there are brighter-sounding headphones. As it is, there is enough treble to enhance details such as percussion, but without much chance of fatigue - it's a good comfortable sound.
Separation and soundstage are excellent; individual instruments can be picked out with the soundstage extending beyond the physical confines of the headphones themselves.
- See more at: http://www.hifiheadphones.co.uk/reviews/sennheiser-urbanite-xl-wireless-review/#sthash.6Ki2EV6v.dpuf
So, what has changed in the BT performance? The physical headphones, of course, as this is a different physical pair of Urbanite XL wireless than I had in the past, but I've had three M2 wireless headphones which all have had bad stuttering. I am still using the same main source - Sony Xperia Z3 Compact - but, crucially, in the last few days my network provider in the UK finally pushed out the Android Lollipop update to the phone. No idea whether that has made the difference and no way of testing this. My Sony MDR-10RBT headphones performed fault free with my Kitkat and with the new Lollipop upgrade, so I doubt it. Just thought I'd share my experience, though.
Am I tempted to go back to the M2 wireless to see if they have the same stutter-free performance now? 'No' is the simple answer. Properly functioning BT would be one more mark in the plus side of those headphones, but I would still be unable to use the M2 wireless connected via BT on my daily commute, as the ANC interferes too much with the sound quality with bumps and clicks, as I have said. I'm also pretty happy now, with the XL wireless, so that will end my search for BT headphones. They do all I want them to and sound better than the 10RBTs - less bloated in the bass, and faster. The fact that they have a microphone and remote control when connected wired is also a bonus, and I have already bought a Brainwaves headphone case from Amazon to keep them nice and safe when travelling, given that the supplied pouch is inadequate in my view for that purpose.
So, this is probably my last post in the M2 wireless headphone thread. Hope anyone suffering 'Stuttergate' finds a solution - my experiences with the XL wireless suggest that it is possible, although I'm unsure whether this is down to something in the headphones (better QC?), the source system software (better BT performance with BT4.0 devices?) or a combination of both.