If you will listen mostly to those genres, while not on the go, and want lots of treble and air then IE800 are for you. They are very good for rock and metal. However, it seems like you describing something like Dunu Titan 1 IEMs and they very slightly warm, have less bass (are almost bass-anemic when compared to IE800), have very good detail, well extended and very airy treble and are also very good for rock and metal. If you think IE800 are bass light and very neutral/uncolored you can not be farther away from the truth. They do have "more treble and air" but they are not neutral and uncolored at all. On the other hand,"overwhelming SE846 warmth and overwhelming bass punch that takes over the entire sound" is just almost offensive assumption. We´re talking about SE846 not SE215. Shure developers spent years to make 1000$ crap IEM that sounds just like SE215 or Beats IEMs and now are laughing at us all? Srry for that but hey. Does not make sense. Bass is not overwhelming at all, it is punchy but in the right, correct, unoffensive way. You can change the sound drastically with filters and with white filters and Dunu tips SE846 are bass light compared to "overwhelming warmth" of IE800. Now, on the natural/neutral/uncolored side of things - SE846 all the way. They are more neutral of the two (to me anyway). Their main problem is that they lack more treble extension so the sound stage is more vertical (deep) than horizontal (wide). Sound is thick (compared to IE800), yes, but everything sounds natural and right. However the coloration of IE800 is unique and that is what makes them so special, treble is almost on the "thin" side but it is actually very resolving, refined and airy, sound stage is huge, mids are recessed (when compared directly to SE846) but stunningly clear and textured, bass is somewhat opposite of SE846´s bass (not as tight or focused). The sound signature of IE800 makes them perfect for rock and metal, SE846 will sound right, neutral, natural but not as alive as IE800, so you will appreciate a lot the SE846´s presentation but you will probably love IE800´s approach.