CS 1.6 --- 9/10
Starcraft --- 10/10
Madden --- 10/10
Tiger Woods Golf --- 8/10
I stick with the best on PC
Starcraft 1?
Im not only playing it but streaming a tournament of it on sundays, and I participated in it (not many to go thou, semifinals and finals left).
Starcraft 1 was my introduction to competitive multiplayer and till this day, I never got bored of it. (unreal tournament original comes a distant second and dark souls 1 a distant 3rd). 10/10 (Probably the only game I ever gave a 10/10).
My only problem is that Broodwar is like a drug, the more you take the more you want, and thats a problem when you are 32 (no wonder Im single
.)
Diablo 2 was my favorite "relax game".
Not sure if my characters are still up (I try to keep them in b.net) but I created some of the most OP builds out there back in the day (I even forced one patch to come out, I think it was 1.10 when I figured out that blood golem+Iron maiden meant you were IMBA).
Gotta love diablo 2 for having some many crazy stuff people came up with. 8.5/10 (While the game was great, it clearly had flaws, not all of them good).
Warcraft 3 was never my cup of tea (after controlling massive armies in broodwar, controlling 10 units seems... not challenging. Im not saying its not, Im saying how it felt for me).
Nostalgia... oh well
.