castleofargh
Sound Science Forum Moderator
- Joined
- Jul 2, 2011
- Posts
- 10,512
- Likes
- 6,159
There was an interesting link over on the Pono Community site of a web interview with NY. The best I heard there was his comment that, with MP3 compression you hear 5% of the music and with 24/192 you hear 100% of the music. His question was, which would you prefer? He also spoke of the new firmware, which will have "the Revealer, a built-in app which will take a hi-res file in the Pono and play it back at a variety of lower resolutions so that a listener can hear the difference(s) between them. Before anyone comes on here and bashes, listen to what he says. The Revealer is at about 10 minutes in. The whole thing is interesting, especially when he discusses who can hear better sound and who can't. "Good on you."Enjoy.
http://twit.tv/show/triangulation/199
BTW, I'm enjoying all of the posts of people who try the Pono thinking ehh, and then go wow when they actually hear it. That was my response as well at Xmas and I certainly got beaten up a bunch for saying, WOW here in Head-Fi threads. Looks like a lot of us are now in the wow camp. And yes, if you try it in balanced mode, it's double wow. No kidding.
I'm guessing a couple of folks here didn't actually watch the interview before posting. See, that's sort of the point. Listen to what the man says (oh, and listen to the equipment being discussed). Certainly if you folks actually listened to a Pono you might have a different view. Since you didn't, and this comes down, again, to an opinion (yeah, yeah, to you it's science but to everyone else it's an opinion) why not try a Pono with a CD-rip 16/44 (let alone something higher) BEFORE you come on a Pono site? And, if you HAVE actually at least listened to a higher re file (though I'm fairly certain you haven't with a Pono) and can't tell the difference between it and an MP3, is that our problem or yours? BTW, that was ALSO discussed in the interview. Had you watched it.
I can hear the difference between an iPod and a Pono, and I'm only a few years younger than NY (btw, had you actually watched the video you would have seen/heard him discuss this very point).
Everyone at this site is constantly buying/trading/selling/buying more equipment, so how come a Pono not allowed in the club? Why can't Pono say how good it is? What is wrong with selling people something they will enjoy? If they won't they don't have to buy it. Advertising is just that.
If people want to enjoy hi-res, why do you feel it so important to trumpet how worthless it is? Do you stand outside the food store telling the folks buying gluten-free products that they are being duped? Because science says the vast (VAST!) majority of them are.
If MP3 is so good, why don't musicians record on it to begin with?
Why is it so important to come to this site and tell us happy foo...er.... users of 16/44 and higher with our stu....er...waste-of-money Ponos that we are misguided?
Why, lastly, do your knees jerk so much at the mere mention of something being better than MP3? Let it go. Have an ice cream. Read a book. Listen to some music. Enjoy life.
and off you go putting words into my mouth for the sole purpose of playing the victim in a plot of your own making.
I ask you not to do it and to have a little respect for what people are posting, and your answer is a textbook model of strawman argument creating your own questions and answers with no regard to what I actually wrote.
for the sake of it, here is my answer to your post:
I obviously couldn't stand a full hour of that crap video(both content and support). I went up to 20mn or something, and I feel like I made a huge effort already. but in just that time, he indeed went and said that "mp3 is 5%" crap again. and that was, if you ever bother to read what we wrote, the only point we were making. it isn't true and there is no way the difference is 95%, so why repeat it nonstop?
nobody was trying to tell people what to do or what they are allowed to listen to, and of course where did you see me trying to say that mp3 was so good? that's all in your invented discussion we're supposedly having. I didn't write that, meat01 didn't write that. I don't even know what to say. am I now supposed to argue with my fictional self because when I disagree with him?
this is sick.