The Oppo PM-1 with alternate lambskin earpads are
clear winners in terms of sheer upper-mid and treble resolution/transparency of an exceptionally fine and nuanced quality.
The layering and dynamic "bloom" of the instruments--emanating like bursts of fireworks--on
John Williams Conducts John Williams: The Star Wars Trilogy (SONY 1990) are remarkable. Definitely a BIGGER sense of everything--at least for me--with these alternate pads.
The PM-1's resolution and detail [easily] bettered the AKG K812 on these tracks, IMHO. Track 7, "The Asteroid Field", is a thrilling/captivating listen with the Oppos!
Good Stuff!!!
Just yesterday I was telling a friend about having mixed experiences with the alternate pads.
On one hand, when I listen to music that is not mastered and mixed as well as it could be,
or it is compressed into a lower resolution format, the alternate pads sound very bright and even gives the music a fake or unnatural sound at times.
Even with just rock/pop music in general, it can still sound unnatural sometimes.
With those situations, I find that when I switch to the original earpads, they sound much better for that type of music.
However, when I then switch to some very well recorded and mixed classical and jazz music,
I find the complete opposite result to be true.
When that type of music is being played, the original pads sound too dark when compared to the alternate pads.
When using the alternate pads with this type of music, it's as if a heavy veil is lifted and the sound becomes more clear with better fidelity.
So I am stuck in between recommending either pads as a best solution 100% of the time.
I think the original pads are better for 'rock" and maybe even "blues' too, but it would depend on what particular style of blues. 'Classical' and 'jazz' are better with the alternate pads.
Don't ask me about 'country' or 'rap' as those aren't my usual listening preference, and much dance and modern heavy bass music is so muddled in the mix anyway,
I don't think it matters which pads you use for those genres, but the alternate pads may be slightly better just to keep the low end clearer when possible.
As another option, IF your playback device has a decent EQ that can be applied to your music,
then using the alternate pads 100% of the time is doable within my scenarios listed above.
You can use the EQ to tame the hard brightness of some of the most compromised recordings.
Likewise, I like to use it to give a very flat EQ but with a pinch of a boost in the low end... just my personal preference.