Quote:
Originally Posted by saturnine
Yeah, you might be shot and/or tortured, but Christians wouldn't be burning down buildings, causing riots and killing random people over a simple cartoon. Many Christians around the world feel persecuted, do you see them going around starting up another "Crusade"? I feel that there is a lot of built up tension in the Muslim world that needs to be let out, albeit at a different avenue than physical violence.[/i]
|
This is a core difference between cultures. Now I don't excuse the bad behavior of the extremists, but realize that when 100,000 people protest it's really only 0.1% of those that are actually going to go out and suicide bomb and/or kidnap people. Most are just genuinely angered or are buying into mob logic. This isn't a Muslim/Arab trait either. The US race riots or even riots after NBA championships are just ways for people to get in on something bigger than themselves.
Now, regarding the 'pent up tension' - this is a major difference between cultures. Western cultures see time as moving in one direction, and the past is something to let go. The future is something to be treated like a crop. Sow good seeds today and reap rewards later, but there's nothing you can do about yesterday. Better to move on and look forward.
Not every culture looks at the world this way!
For example, Hindu's think of life as circular. The past is very important, and for those who belive in reincarnation someone else's past can affect their present.
The Arab/Muslim world places enormous weight in the past. It guides every aspect of their culture. It's intrinsic to them as a people. The western world has a left multiple scars on the Arab/Muslim culture dating back 1000's of years. Let's not debate who did what, that's beside the point. The real issue is those scars are there, and they're very real to a large portion of the world.
I've heard the Arab/Muslim concept of time referred to as a tapestry, with each new year adding layers the cloth, but at no point is the cloth ever looked at as 'behind' them. It defines them.
This doesn't mean there's no hope for the future. There are many moderate Muslims, and many have Westernized. I think the path to modernizing the very traditional Muslim world is through assistance, not conquest. Yes, there are many leaders there who won't be very helpful to anything associated with the west, but if we could work with the more moderate countries and demonstrate a better way of life then it would slowly creep in.
Many Muslim immigrants come to the US to escape the oppression - my fiance's family did. Her mom was a rebellios female doctor and that didn't fly in Saudi Arabia. They came to the US because they could afford to...but many are poor and are just stuck in that, just like poor folks in the US are stuck in housing projects. Like American poor who have a much greater tendency toward crime and ignorant ghetto-logic, those stuck in other countries are similarly defined by their environment.
--Illah