So I've decided to keep this headphone, at the very least just out of good faith for Monoprice and their customer service. The brief version, my Liquid Platinum amp burned out a few weeks ago. I bought it used so I thought I was boned, but I got in touch with the guy I bought it from, he helped me RMA it. We told Monoprice "Uhhhhh... it was a wedding present! Please send this new person the replacement rather than the person who originally bought it." And they did! So, since they were kind enough to make that work, I'll keep this headphone.
This is still a gorgeously detailed and musical headphone with incredible sub-bass extension, but it's that sub-bass that kind of mislead me in regards to what kind of music this headphone excels at. I thought this would be an absolute hard rock and heavy metal monster with sub-bass like it has, but it kept just underwhelming me with those genres. But it's becoming clear to me that this headphone is just too laid back for that kind of use. It's not lazy by any means, but it's... it's a gentle touch kind of headphone. To steal a Jeremy Clarkson metaphor, it's a dentist's drill when I want a sledgehammer.
That said, when I apply this instead to... really, anything other than hard rock or metal, that's when it really starts to become clear to me where this headphone excels. It just takes all the little rough edges off of your music, adds a little touch of polish and sparkle and air, and delivers you this extremely pleasant, silky, detailed experience.
It sounds like the HE6SE V2 would be that wild, energetic rock monster that I'm wanting the M1570 to be for hard rock and metal. But so far, applying this headphone to just about any other genre is really proving to be very enjoyable.