Quote:
I want to get a HDMI matrix switch to connect the blurayplayer and the dune hd to the realiser. Would this work?
On a recommendation earlier in this thread, I tried using
this Monoprice 4x2 Matrix Switch along with my Yamaha RX-V863 which only had one HDMI output. At the time I also had an Oppo BDP-83 which also only has one HDMI output (for audio and video combined). I had the Oppo configured to put out LPCM audio over HDMI.
So I sent the HDMI output from the Oppo to one of the four HDMI inputs on the Switch. By sending input 1 to both outputs 1 and 2, this switch really acts as an "HDMI port multiplier", so I connected HDMI output 1 to the AVR (for video use only) and HDMI output 2 (for audio use only) to the Realiser. Note that this is really exactly how things work now for me, since I have purchased a BluRay player which itself has two HDMI outputs, one for video and a second for audio.
Anyway, I tried it briefly, and while I was able to get it to work perfectly it didn't quite work for me as conveniently as I'd hoped. The problem comes because depending on the power-on sequence and connections in-place at the time the BluRay player is powered on (way back at the start of the device "source chain") the HDMI audio handshake that takes place between the source player and the multiple HDMI-enabled devices in the relay chain going all the way down to the Switch and beyond (where there are now two end-devices on the chain which can accept audio via HDMI: (a) the HDTV via the AVR, and (b) the Realiser), the BluRay player source device has to make a decision about the format of digital audio delivered via HDMI.
And as is the rule, the "lowest common denominator must be supported", i.e. the HDTV which in my case can only accept 2-channel PCM stereo via its HDMI input. No multi-channel can be accepted. So the BluRay player forces its digital audio output to only be 2-channel PCM stereo, rather than the desired multi-channel LPCM (which of course CAN be accepted by the Realiser which is connected to output 2 of the Matrix Switch). It wasn't sufficient to simply have the HDTV powered off when the BluRay player was powered on. There seemed to be some "memory" of the attached HDTV in the Matrix Switch as long as the HDMI cables were still connected, and now the BluRay player always sent its audio output in the undesired 2-channel PCM stereo mode.
I found that if I temporarily disconnected the HDTV from the Matrix Switch and turned the BluRay player on, with the Matrix Switch initially powered off but then powered on after the BluRay player had been powered on, that the HDMI audio handshake occurring between the Oppo and the Realiser through the Matrix Switch would work properly and multi-channel LPCM was the negotiated result. And then, if I now plugged the HDTV back into the switch, the Oppo would for some lucky reason not re-negotiate the HDMI audio handshake and drop down to 2-channel PCM stereo! Instead, it would continue to deliver the originally negotiated multi-channel LPCM!! So I was now able to listen to multi-channel audio via the Realiser's HDMI input (through output 2 of the Matrix Switch, from the BluRay player still delivering multi-channel LPCM audio via HDMI output) as well as watch video on my HDTV via HDMI from output 1 of the Matrix Switch).
So I had to do this anytime I wanted to start watching a BluRay movie session. I felt it inconvenient and unacceptable.
Instead, I re-purposed my Oppo BDP-83 BluRay player (with its single HDMI output) to a second location in my home, and bought a new BDP-93 with two HDMI outputs... and which was obviously the true 100% for solution, for both function and convenience. Today, the current model is the BDP-103 if you wanted to buy one new, as the BDP-93 is no longer made.
If you're interested in buying that Monoprice Matrix Switch from me (which is currently back in its box, on the shelf in my "parts graveyard") just let me know.