Quote:
Originally Posted by mjay1977 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Styling...
I have heard alot of comments about the styling on the headphones, some good, some bad but all very valid and useful.
How here's a question...
At each Shure model price point, what model would you consider the design benchmark ie. the best designed headphone at the given price?
Benchmark against:
-SRH240 ($59)
-SRH440 ($99)
-SRH840 ($199)
Please pick one model each in these general price points to benchmark against the Shure model. I am curious to know what everyone thinks is a good design vs. a bad design and why...
Thanks!
|
Design quality is almost wholly independent of price point. There's both good and bad looking headphones of practically every price, so I'm not sure that's the best way to judge the competition.
Instead, Shure needs to come up with its own distinctive and elegant look. At the moment, the 240 looks like a Dr. Dre Beats ripoff, and the 440 and 840 look like a bigger Sony V6 reboot with Beyer cues in the supports. There's no cohesiveness or distinctiveness to the lineup.
If you're looking for good examples, look to AKG. Almost all (with the exception of the DJs) of their headphones have that distinctive AKG look, with the color scheme and silver accents, but each model still looks elegant in its own manner. The whole line is free of the curse of generic black plastic--not that black or plastic can't look good if done right.
Denon has also developed a distinctive but elegant look; a quick glance through their lineup is self-explanatory.
Aside from these solid examples, there are
a lot of ugly headphones. Ultrasones sound fantastic, but have a certain ugliness about them, despite the quality materials. Grados are similarly great headphones, but the lower end has a distinctively cheap feel to them (particularly the SR60s), and the whole line has a very handmade-in-Brooklyn feel to it. It's not necessarily bad, but maybe an acquired taste.
From the aesthetic foundation Shure already has, I think they should really end up tending more in the Denon direction than Grado. It honestly shouldn't be that hard to replace the current boring plastic with some of the nicer plastics and metals from the earbud line. This may push up prices a bit, but frankly I--and surely plenty of ordinary consumers--would be much more likely to buy them if they looked better, even if they cost an extra $25 or so.
Also, you need to integrate that wire over the headband. That's just bad design as is, which is sure to generate lots of warranty claims from people who chucked them in a backpack, etc. and had it severed by any number of too-sharp objects. I do prefer single-entry over double, but not at a cost like that.
Apologies for not precisely answering your question; I'm just tired of all the best headphones being terribly ugly.