So, I got bored and decided to finally play a little shootout between all my iem's. Playing "Magnets" by Disclosure and Lorde, in 320 kbps through Foobar at 24/96 on my smsl m2.
ED4 with knockoff hybrids
The highs and bass are present in quite a normal fashion with the mids definitely sucked out after listening to my monks and HDS3. This makes the iem sound so dead and dull; indifferent. Lorde’s vocals seem behind me but sound pretty normal and have a decent weight to them without a sibilant sparkle to be heard. All the drums in the mid are completely sucked out and it’s hard to really hear them coherently. All I hear is the sub bass thump of the drums really, yet the high mids going into the treble are definitely there but seem to get a little mixed up together, making them a bit incoherent. The high treble seems a bit rolled off too, although I originally found it a bit sibilant. I think it’s just the song.
HDS3 with stock tips
It just feels right, lol! The sub bass isn’t as apparent, seeming to trade weight to give the mids space to breathe and be heard. I can hear Lorde literally singing into my ears, but there’s a certain piece of percussion that seems sucked out or drowned out which just happens to be my favorite instrument in the entire song. It’s like two metal dowels being struck together and just seems to be a bit lost in the iem’s presentation. It might be due to a slight V shape in the sound signature, with the apex being on this single instrument’s part of the spectrum. All the sounds are well separated, although it sounds a bit congested at times with too many sounds occurring at once.
ED10 with blue whirlwinds
Is there a sub in my room or am I just confused.. Lol! There is so much sub bass, I forgot how fun these things sound! There is beyond enough bass to motivate anyone to bob their head with the beat and burst out into dance, with a super lively V shaped presentation. The mids get a little lost, they get drowned out a bit by the sub bass and sparkly, slightly sibilant highs. I really forgot how much I enjoyed these iem’s since I got the ED4’s! If you’re a basshead that loves a decently coherent iem and can tolerate the fit, these are definitely a need to have. If you DJ, these should probably be a force to be reckoned with as a monitor for basslines. The fit really turns me off as it hurts my ears after a while, and I’m a bit sensitive to the extra sparkle on the top end of the treble.
ZS1 with KZ comply style foams
These actually have more in common with the ED10 than anything else I own, if I may say so. A few head-fi’ers know how I feel about the sound of these but they fit almost perfectly with this song.. What is happening!? The bass doesn’t seem to drown out as much of the music as the ED10’s but the midbass is boosted a bit too much and just booms too much. Lorde’s voice doesn’t sparkle as well, I’m guessing it’s due to the sub bass and midbass being so heavily boosted that everything else sounds a little off. Previously, I thought that these sounded hollow but it’s actually due to the midbass booming so heavy that it seems to give sounds a sort of echo.
VE Monk with full foam cover
These sound a bit like the HDS3, if they were wide open. The sub bass isn’t very apparent as I don’t get a good seal without holding them in. When I do hold them in, the subbass is well extended but a tad boosted possibly, with an added sparkle on top that I’m not overly fond of but can definitely tolerate. These sound a lot more like my HD598SE than the others, and the open back sound is definitely a favorite for me nowadays. The music can breathe and just resonates beautifully. Lorde’s voice is just right infront of my face and every single instrument has beautiful separation with room to breathe. The sound gets a little congested at times but it’s not as bad as any of the other iem’s. Comfort definitely varies for this pair of buds as I just lay them in my ears and can wear them forever, but if I vie for a complete seal, they’re easily less comfortable than the ED10’s. Also, these play beautifully with Dolby headphone/virtual surround due to the openness and allow for a great immersion in video games or silent cinema.
P3 with knockoff Hybrids
I really haven’t listened to these since I’ve chanced upon KZ and I definitely forgot how good these really are. Once again, Lorde’s voice is in my head but sounds great. The mid bass is just barely boosted but the sub bass rolls off so quickly that there’s barely enough weight to hear it.. I think all I can hear is the midbass, really. The highs seem to roll off smoothly and don’t interrupt the song’s presentation and all the instruments are separated just enough to hear everything. They’re unbelievably light and so comfortable and sound good, a bit like the HD3 I’d say, just missing some highs and lows. (No highs, no lows; must be Bose LOL)
Best overall – HDS3 tied with the Monks, I’d just say they’ve got different things that they equally excel at.
Bass – ED10 by far, the midbass boom on ZN1 is just a pita for me.
Comfort – P3 or HDS3, they’re just so light and vanish into your ears.
Order I’d rate the earphones I’ve owned:
HDS3, Monk
Zircons (no longer have, can’t really say much)
P3
ED4
ED10
ZN1, P2
Assorted Skullcandies
Funny how carltonh just hit the nail on the head as I got ready to post this lol! The ED4 just sound bland missing their mids, imo.