Recently, I started arguing with my buddy about
budget headphones.
Not that it was intentional.
My initial argument about IEMs being a better choice is that they have a greater chance of being "bang for the buck", simply because it's a smaller form-factor, it requires fewer materials, which then means there is a greater chance that these materials would have more quality compared to the full-sized headphones(for the same price).
You can't buy a bag of cigarettes and then pretend that you can buy a submarine fully loaded with them for just $1, do you?
I'm not saying that it's that simple, and there are some complications behind the scenes.
He says IEMs were created as a continuation of hearing aids
and their purpose is for musicians and not audiophiles. So I thought, even then,
what kind of issues we're dealing with if we use IEMs instead of full-sized headphones? I know, they lack soundstage because of physical distance to the eardrum and small-sized drivers. And there's also a resonance peak at 8k Hz. Two things. What else? Why it's not supposed to be used as something that you would consider for high-quality listening experience?
Later on, he says "what about THD(total harmonic distortion) in these IEMs"?
I said: ok, there's 1-2% in peaks even when we're using Knowles BA drivers.
Then he said: is that not enough?
So I started to think, theoretically losing 1-2% in peaks shouldn't be much of a worry. I also knew that BA drivers do have a somewhat .. high THD? And I said about that. Then I asked him, do you think that because of THD, full-sized headphones in the same price range would sound definitely better than, for example, KZ ZAX? He said yes, of course.
I looked it up what can we have for just $60.
AKG K92(clickable).
I sent this link, and he immediately says: these are going to be worse. They have a dynamic driver that still has a high THD. I say: ok, what's the better option?
He says. Planars. Their THD is incomparable to anything else.
I thought that it was a joke and googled what's the cheapest option available. Stax SR L300. Hey, just x10 times more expensive. Haha.
On that note, I understood that our discussion is over.
Ok, guys, what's your thoughts? Do Campfire Audio, Noble, Astell&Kern and other Summit-Fi brands treat everyone as idiots and sell their expensive IEMs just for fun? I don't think there would be any market if IEMs are that bad compared to the full-sized headphones.