Well I got my S4 (whites) this morning, it was actually a spur of the moment thing. I was asked by my parents what I wanted and I didn't really need anything for christmas but then I remembered I could really use a good pair of headphones for when I am away from home, like at work, for my ipod touch. So I did about a night of researching on reviews and came up with these.
I've had 2 main sets of headphones before, the grado 60 and my current set, sennhiesers 280 pros. $70-$100 range. Both of these headphones are awesome, the grado 60s were perfect but really open to outside noises (and the reverse) and the 280 pros had a great sound seal but lacked a bit in the bass (I would have gotten another set of the grados but the 60s have horrible construction flaws and the cable was awful, it broke in like 3 different places and needed to be spliced, one of them was inside the ear casing that is sealed up with glue). However nothing that couldn't be fixed with messing with the EQ (although it was a lot harder to get the 280 pros to sound good on my ipod). From what I read however, I probably wouldn't be able to find as good as IEMs in the same price range because they are smaller and would cost more to shrink quality drivers even smaller, and after all the reviews I have read from IEMs in the $70 range I wasn't far off. They all had at least a small amount of people that wern't happy with the sound of their IEM. I decided on the S4's because they seem to have gotten alot of spotlight and yet still maintained descent scores, so it was a safe bet I was going to get at least something listenable.
So I opened my S4s this morning and popped em in, and right away I pretty much knew everything about em.. and alot of it coincides with what people have said here. Great lows and mids, with descent highs but a very noticable distortion. I knew right off the bat that I was gonna need to break these in pretty hard, so I started by pretty much leaving them to play my top rated music tracks (so at best, it would learn to break in with my fav types of music) and left it for about 8 hours. Its a start. Just before shutting it down I sampled the audio and noticed the highs were less harsher but still a bit of distortion. After going to sleep and coming back another 8 hours (now) I picked em up and happy to note that a lot of the harshness/distortion has really gone away. The head phones really do hug the treble to the point of drowning out the mids a little bit (Although I am using the rock eq setting which if I am not mistaken is a low bell curve that I like to use so much, so I am already lowering mids and emphasing lows and highs ) but overall I am happy with the range now, and there is not enough (if any) of that distortion in the highs that really made me wince.
So aside from being a little moody with highs.. I am happy to note that lows and mids are really beautiful, drums and strings as well as vocals are clear and very warm (Something I loved about the grados and missed dearly on the sennhiesers). All in all I am happy to have found em, they are also very comfortable and the size is great for putting in my ipod touches pouch (dual sleaved) to carry around with me. Btw the type of music I listen to and used for testing is pretty wide, but I draw the line at rap and country. The music I favor most is the instrumental fusion types, from electronics types like Yuki Kajiura to rock/gothic like Hans Zimmer and Therion. Both types of music use modern instruments like guitars and drums mixed with orchestra strings and percussions, as well as lots of female chorus vocals.
ADDED: Well I found something very interesting out. When I woke up tonight I decided to try the smaller gel slips. I noticed quite abit of difference in all sound levels and wondered if the gel inserts made it... boy DID IT. I stuck the middle sized gels caps on and the annoying treble distortion was audible again, I also noticed the bass was a little louder. So it seemed that I couldn't push them in far enough with the mid sized gel slips and it emphasized the high and low sounds artificially. So the small covers are back on and I am enjoying them much better.