I made an enquiry to VOX about their DSD playback, as the screen shows 88.2 kHz in the screen when playing back a DSD track via the iDSD Nano. I wanted to ask if this meant that the DSD was being converted to PCM. This is the response:
DoP means "DSD over PCM", that's the point - DSD is first converted to PCM, then delivered. VOX shows the actual output PCM sample rate here.
VOX cannot play DSD native (as many other players also) because it would require to support DSD audio interfaces which currently we do not.
So basically, the are saying that DoP requires a conversion to PCM, but I was under the impression that DoP resulted in native DSD, just wrapped in the PCM stream? Other media players have DoP and PCM conversion as two separate options. So it appears that VOX cannot deliver native DSD yet?
Hi,
You are correct in your assumptions.
Here is the DoP industry standard document:
http://dsd-guide.com/dop-open-standard
- so you can see DoP is not "Converting DSD to PCM".
- if the device plays DSD viaDoP both the iDSD nano and Micro will decode it and show the correct colour for DSD.
- if they show the sample rate as 88K or similar then it is not being sent as DoP DSD but converted to standard PCM.
Sony can show DSD output as PCM and DSD???
For example, we demo with the Sony Xperia and Z2 (tablets and phones).
They all have the Walkman Hi-Res app. It "plays" DSD but it actual transcodes to PCM176.6 (nice quality but not the point).
So using the Walkman app to play DSD, the nano / micro iDSD will show PCM 176!
BUT using UAPP to play DSD on the same Sony devices, the nano / micro will show DSD playing.
By the way, we love these Sony devices but we are just highlighting how things work "behind the curtain".
We hope this sheds more light.