Ok, since I have the titles being discussed here, I gave them a listen myself.
I took two tracks off the Carpenters Singles SACD, converted them to flac (so I can play them back as PCM), then played both back-to-back, first as native DSD, then as flac, from local storage. To
@Silverlinings comment about recording age, this
does hold true, since I have a few other versions of these tracks (Carpenters Gold SACD, Best of Carpenters etc.), and in each case the mastering of the track is slightly different to the version on Singles. That said, as a longtime Carpenters fan, both the tracks I used (
We've Only Just Begun and
Rainy day and Mondays) I know intimately well, having listened to them dozens of times before for more than 30 years now, and both sound fantastic with the RS6 and IE 900 (which some people liken to an improved Z1R, but that's a different discussion). Excellent bass, for the recording year that is, clean treble, not too bright at all, and Karen's vocals are, as always, sublime, with tiny details in her voice and throat easily discernible). What's more, I can tell
very little difference, if any, in the same tracks played back as Hi-Res flac (so using the acual R2R DAC), meaning the DSD playback is not degrafing the quality of these files at all.
I'm not the world's biggest Diana Krall fan (sorry
@Silverlinings), in that I appreciate her work and use many of her DSD and hi-res tracks to demo new gear because they're so well made, but I don't regualrly listen to her as much as I do other stuff. That said, I have the
Live In Paris SACD/DSD, and without even having to convert to flac, I can immediately tell that playback is of the highest quality. Does it match super high-end DSD-capable DACs? I don't know, but to my ears, I'd happily use this DSD to demo the RS6 with the IE 900 to anyone looking for a high-end portable system for hi-res/hi-fi sound.
Please note: none of the above was done to disparage
any of the opinions shared before or deny
@littlexx26's or
@ScubaDrunk's experiences. Rather, since I had these albums and am very familiar with them, it was useful to play them back for myself with the RS6 to see if my particular unit displayed any of the issues they pointed out, and to the best of my hearing, preferences or opinion it doesn't. This is why I feel it's important to listen to the same music on the same gear when comparing. If you're following the discussion, consider it just another data point.