It just seems like a lot of plastic for the price. DIY speakers made into a headphone instead of a proper headphone design. The technology is more than interesting, perhaps it will give a new, fresh spin to the whole industry. But being one of the heaviest options out there won't help.
I would like to hear more on this assessment:
1. betula, have you demo'ed any of the prototypes? If so, which parts do you see as "a lot of plastic for the price" and not enough [fill in the blank] wood, leather, etc.? One could look at a Senn HD800 and see a lot of plastic as well, but I think it's put to pretty good use. I love my Audi cars, and they've got a fair bit of plastic in and around them as well, also put to good use.
2. "DIY speakers" is based on what? There's no question the AMT transducers could be thought of as DIY, inasmuch as HEDD claims they hand-build each one. But that's the kind of craftsmanship I don't mind paying for, so long as it's not at the sacrifice of QC. None of the pics look DIY to me.
3. What is a "proper headphone design" in your opinion? I look at my collection of headphones, ranging from Darths to the SR1a, and not a one of them looks like the other. Which of them is "proper"? If anything, the chamber demands of the AMT driver that DecentLevi mentioned may necessitate this design, and it may be viewed as just as "proper" as anything else. I am sure Abyss could tell me the merits of their design and why it is quite proper, though I currently believe otherwise.
4. You may be correct in this assessment: "But being one of the heaviest options out there won't help." Personally, I doubt it. Weight did not seem to impede Audez'e's success, and with a price tag of half of the LCD-4, the early impressions of the HEDD suggest a real potential upside of success [if they can meet demand].
Not trying to flame or flame-bait here. I am genuinely curious where these assessments originate. I am asking because, when I look at the little bits of info we have so far [mostly marketing and a few impressions], the design appears reasonably "clean," and the technology seems intriguing. I acknowledge design is often a matter of personal taste. For example, I find the Abyss TC preposterously ugly and ungainly, but that's just me, and it's kept me from enjoying a headphone that I agree
sounds marvelous. Others find the SR1a's appearance quite odd. Unlike DecentLevi, I haven't had the opportunity to see, feel, or hear the HEDD in person. It's not clear to me if you have. But until any of us does, we're all just speculating. [And that includes me.]