No matter how good the Starfield (or any other IEM for that matter) sounds, I can never ignore:
- The cord wrapped around my ears
- The knowledge that I'm tethered to another device
- Maintenance of multiple connection points
- Finding good device "synergy" because impedance can be a real pain sometimes, especially with Chi-Fi equipment
And that's coming from someone who served 12 years and had plenty of problem when trying to do things like clean a bilge with a wired set. Younger, dumber me thought there was no issue doing that with a set of Shure SE530 and I had to field-medic those things ten ways east of Sunday.
Moral of the story is there's a use case for
both, and it seems like every 100 posts or so that someone else comes in and says "TWS Bad, IEM Good" rather than even attempt to keep things within the context of the thread title.
Are we there yet? I'd argue yes. Bluetooth protocols have significantly bridged the gap in wired/wireless throughput since even aptX was initially announced. Both major players and boutique brands have functional, successful, quality-built products (with some exceptions in the mix) that we get the privilege of talking about on here, whenever we want. aptX Adaptive-capable sets are beginning to roll out. HiBy's even willing to step outside of the mainstream and worked on their own Hi-Res-capable BT protocol.
It's an exciting time for TWS.
I would agree with almost everything you said, except.... I would argue that TWS aren't there yet, wireless is closer, but still NOT quite... I DO like where the prices of TWS is heading. It's more affordable than when there were only a few names out there, but the sound quality is just not close (if I'm to be honest). There are a lot of "great" sounding TWS out there, but they really can't compare to a good set of IEMs. This is not really a fair statement though, because (normally) you would need to pay a large amount to get a set that are THAT noticeably better (leaving out some of the great Chi-fi stuff like Tin Hifi P1 <heavenly sound>). The sound is good, just not as refined. I AM pretty spoiled though, listening to audiophile grade headphones destroys one's ability to go back to something like "Skullcandy" LOL.
On the wireless front, though I have to do some serious critical listening to hear a difference sometimes. I have a set of Hifiman Deva, and I CAN hear a difference between wired and BT, but I gotta' say, it is not large at all, and might even just be the different coloring added by the amp of my DAP as opposed to the BT amp/DAC.
BUT.... I am not complaining about TWS (yet), and am content to keep trying new ones until I find some I REALLY like. I say not yet, because if the industry becomes stagnant and decides they are good enough, THEN I will complain...
On a shocking front, I have found a new winner for me (outta' the ones I have so far). You won't believe it, but it is actually the Hifiman TWS600. I can see now why they were originally $199 (since dropped all the way to $50). They have the capability/technicalities to be amazing sounding, just not out of the box. Out of the box they are SOOOO mid forwards that the upper mids (especially female vocals and high males) not only dominate all, but are shrill to the point of pain.
Now, I have been able to EQ that part down and they do sound good, but I tried something new the other day, and now they are absolutely amazing. Yeah ya' have to work at it a bit to get them there, but for $50..... Anyhow, I have used Neutron for a while now, but didn't realize it had something called Auto-EQ. I found there was a profile for the TWS600 and downloaded it. They sound terrific (for those that like the Harmon curve), but I wasn't done there. When a headphone/IEM has well textured and refined bass, I DO like to beef it up a bit, and I always like more treble (it brings out details if it is well implemented on the driver), so in addition to the profile, I set up the following on a 10 band EQ (in Neutron player):
- 31HZ = +10db
- 62Hz = +5db
- 125Hz = +2db
The rest at 0 until you get to:
It is not as much of a V as you might think because of the mid forward presentation of the TWS600 already. If you are using android and don't want to pay for the Neutron app, you can install an app called Wavelet, which has the same profiles for free. You can pay to unlock the rest of the functions, but they aren't very good. This app is system wide, so you can set "Auto-EQ" and it will work with any app (that I have come across), then use whatever EQ besides that you want to. I haven't found a profile for Nuarl or MT yet, but I am sure there will be one at some point.
Sorry to run on so long, just thought I would share...