I am like you , i didn't like the black1 which look like stock th-x00 pads ,,
Lotown pads are in the middle between these two ,,
for me they are the most balanced pads ,
but still you have to try it with your amp ,, result deffer with each amp ,,
if you check my old posts ,, first time i tried the lowton pads with audeze deckard amp and i didn't like them ,,
sound stage was heavily reduced and upper bass was to much so i returned to stock pads,
later i updated my gear to the the fostex hpa8 amp , with that i tried the lowton pads again , and it was amazing.
so as you can see results sometimes don't match between members exactly because of these variances in gear ,
beast thing to do, is to try more and more pads with different materials and shapes , and that's what i did
thankfully the headphone design made that easy to replace pads ,
I have all Dekoni pads that fit fostex TH headphones (5 on-hand & 2 coming this month (total 7 pairs))
+ Dekoni TH-X00 Attenuation Rings , which could be used with any pad ,
+ 3 or 4 hifiman HE pads ( velour , leather , extra large ,..)
+ ZMF Ori Pads ,
+ famous pad : Brainwavz Angled pads (most over rated pad here in head-fi)
+ finally the Lotown pads ...
Choices are huge ,, specially with the TH-X00 Attenuation Rings,
to summarize things .. my 3 best pads beside stock are :
Lotown pads (most of the time , best balance for my amp and taste)
Dekoni TH-900 sheep Skin ( if i want relaxed experience )
Dekoni X00 Premium (not sheepskin) for most fun sound with extreme bass - (only with chord mojo)
and i am still experimenting