Very late to this thread, but it was fun to look through. You are not a fan of "Smell of the Game" with its very meme filled lined "bull blazing?" Well, it is a strange song, so I do not blame you. I like it, but one of my favorite songs from Xrd was equally ridiculous "Safe Intoxication".
I was in the closed beta test for Guilty Gear Strive last weekend. It was definitely a beta, so connection issues and lobby issues were excusable. As for gameplay, it definitely felt like a deviation for Xrd. I found I did have some fun with Faust and will probably pick the game up when it comes out. I doubt I will abandon Xrd, even though the netcode sucks and I do not really have a local Guilty Gear scene.
I have started to get into Skullgirls and Melty Blood. Skullgirls' tutorial is quite good for one still relatively new to fighting games like me, though now I have the daunting task of figuring out who I want to play.
Melty Blood felt a bit more basic initially compared to Skullgirls or Xrd but I am starting to appreciate its mechanics and style. Still have no real grasp on the moon system (though I have looked it up, I will need to look it up again). And look up the wiki for some information and tips.