This is definitely a very noticeable buzz, and the volume doesn't even have to be very loud - I can hear it all the way down to -5.00 on the volume scale. It is also clearly related to the asynchronous mode on the unit. I can have it on synchronous - no buzz, then change it, immediately the buzz is present. I have switched it back and forth a bunch of times, and it is ALWAYS there in asynchronous mode, and never in synchronous mode. It also immediately goes away if the USB cable is unplugged - leading me to believe it might be some sort of ground issue, but since it is not present in synchronous mode I am not sure...
I did contact Emo today - they said it should definitely not be doing that. He also told me that they have had a few people report similar problems with both the DC-1 AND the XDA-2. He thought that a USB isolator should fix it, but admitted that it shouldn't be happening in the first place. I haven't tried the USB cable Emotiva sent because it is too short, but that would be odd if it were the problem, since I used the same cable with the XDA-2 and it had no problems, and neither does THIS unit with the same cable in synchronous mode.
In addition, the sound itself is suspect. While I don't have them side by side, both my wife and I think that the XDA-2 sounded better. For the most part, it sounds very clear, but I noticed that the highs seem very harsh - almost unpleasant to listen to, and I notice what almost seems like very quiet static in the highs on occasion. It could just be idiosyncrasies in the recordings that I never noticed before - but it doesn't sound good. If the XDA-2 had lasted more than 2 days I would still just be using that. As it is I am considering changing manufacturers altogether. While everyone else seems to have great luck, I have had two defective units in a row, which is about one more defect than I usually allow before moving on.