CanadianMaestro
Headphoneus Supremus
Hello P,
while you have been listening to Tannhäuser in chunks I have been doing the same with Tristan und Isolde the last couple of days, just finished listening to sides 4-6 on my 5 LP box from EMI P1972 Karajan and the BPO with singers John Vickers Tristan and Helga Dernesch as Isolde and Christa Ludwig as Brangäne and Karl Ridderbusch as King Marke, Walter Berry as Kurvenal and Peter Schreier both as a young Seaman and a Shepherd.
I also have Tristan und Isolde in the classic DGG live take from Bayreuth with Birgit Nilsson.
But I much prefer Karajan's Tristan over DGG's dynamically compressed, thin and wiry take from Bayreuth.
As always imho nobody did "the long line" better than Karajan, and a long line it sure is with this 4 hours plus Opera.
And Helga Dernesch was also a very capable Isolde in her day,not only Birgit Nilsson.
Moreover the superb recording by Wolgang Gülich for EMI, made in the Philharmonie is very coherent and realistic with singers in a real acoustic instead of singing lips pressed close to a mic.
Strongly recommended.
In digital form only available as cd as far as I know.
I have Tannhäuser both on LPs,DGG Birgit Nilsson and the live Janowski set from Pentatone as download.
Incidentally the Janowski was also recorded in the Philharmonie.
But to my taste Tristan is a better work and true milestone in music.
Cheers Christer
Hi C.,
I too have been binging somewhat on Wagner. Boosting my Wagner library, which was quite lean.
Been listening to Lohengrin and Dutchman. Very nice. I must say, his Ring has lost its luster with me -- I tend to like the music more so than the story lines, which drag too much in the Ring.
Fr Lohengrin (in addtn to the Kempe), I've gotten into Kubelik (with Janowitz!) and a recent one with Mark Elder and the Concertgebouw in glorious sound. With Dutchman, it's Bohm/BR/Jones, Stewart, Klemperer/NewPhil, and of course Dohnanyi/VPO. Really Wagner's most accessible opera.
As for Tristan, that's difficult imo. It's Bohm and Solti for me, with both having Nilsson, who is primo Wagner, for me. Carlo Kleiber/Dresden too.
Somehow Karajan doesn't do it for me. The one exception is Meistersinger/Dresden -- he really got it right, with a perfect cast, and a performance for the ages. It's the only MN that I have, no more.
cheers
P.